January - April Letters To The Editor


Coastguardsman gets medal for ocean rescue

Great to read a feel good story during these times of lawsuits, injunctions, and just plain gettin' stressed out over beach access. Job well done. I wish (Coastguardsman Erik Watson) had been there when I got sucked into the barnacles under the Frisco Pier about 10 years ago surfing!
 
David Dunivan
Mechanicsville, Va.


Island People:  Recycler Todd Phillips

 
As homeowners in Salvo, we enthusiastically signed up to Todd's service last year. We always knew that visitors, most of who come from recycling neighborhoods, would gladly contribute on the Outer Banks. Shame on those management companies who have not yet signed up to be custodians of our environment.

Karl and Billi Haug
Walnut Creek, Calif.



An open letter to juniors and seniors and their parents
 
God bless you, Clifford Swain! We all pray that the young and the not so young make good choices for themselves and all of us who love them.

Rosa-Alice Mayo
Hatteras, NC



The village that saved a baby owl

 
This is such a heart-warming story. Thanks to all the people who care so much about our wildlife and their protection.

Rachel Porter
Granite Quarry, N.C.


In times like these, when we're surrounded by so much shallowness and negativity, this was a great story to read. Thanks to all of those involved who stepped up and went the distance for this baby owl.

Michael Lay
Manteo

 
What a fascinating story and even more so since we are privileged to know Amberly, Mike, Eric and Leslie! I hope Mike continues to photograph the owlet, although that may not be possible considering the nest is so high up.

Claude LeSieur
Lewes, Del.



Sock hop raises money for cancer patients

What a wonderful job the committee did in decorating for the sock hop! I wish I could have been there to enjoy the festivities. Thanks for all the great pictures, Donna.

Vicki Fey
St. James City, Fla.



Flightseeing with Dwight Burrus

Beautiful pictures. My husband would love to take a flight over the Outer Banks. We have been in a plane one time (to Alaska and back) and it scared me, badly. Do you have any suggestions how to over come that fear? The Outer Banks has to be as beautiful from the air, it is from the ground. We love Ocarcoke.  We go two times a year and stay weeks at a time. Thanks for sharing the pictures with others. Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful! God did a wonderful thing when he made the beaches of North Carolina, especially the Outer Banks.
What a wonderful story about a wonderful friend! Dwight is very special indeed (as is Deborah) and Jordan has captured him so well. I hope to see much more from this talented writer.

Lynne Foster
Hatteras



I truly enjoyed your article on Dwight. I, along with my brother-in-law, have had the opportunity to fly with him many times. After a lot of convincing, I got my father-in-law, just before he passed away, to go up with us and experience this amazing flight and gentleman. Dwight is as genuine as anybody I have ever met. Every time I see him, it is like we have been friends forever. My wife and I renewed our marriage vows on our 10th anniversary several years ago at the lighthouse. Dwight presided over the ceremony, and it was a truly moving experience. Each flight I take with him is an adventure, and I learn something new about the island, its history, and its people. We'll see him in October, as we do every year. Stay safe and well.

John Holloway
Berlin, Md.


 
A good story for a great guy. Always there to lend a helping hand if you are in need. As Capt. Edgar would say, "You better believe it."

Paul Robinson
Hatteras



Guest Column: ORV rulemaking was out of public sight


 

You go, Dr. Michael A. Berry!

Susan Wyche
Frisco

 
 
Dr. Berry, you have expressed your thoughts very nicely. I appreciate all that you said and hope that you have a wide range of listeners. I, for one, will be sending this information out to many of my friends and hope that they will also pass it on.
It is sad that such a huge decision was made without any comments from those who have to live with the decision's consequences. I hope what is happening in Hatteras will make national news or commentary. I don't know what it takes to get the word out to the world about what is happening to this unique area of North Carolina. I have written to every national TV station, large radio station, and newspaper, and still no one seems to care about how easy it is for large, well-financed environmental groups to undermine the economy and well being of small communities who depend on tourism/fishing for their livelihoods. I hope everyone will send this information to everyone they know.  Maybe someone will have the right contact to get the word out.

Betty Russell
Martinsburg, W.Va.



Mike Berry has expressed here what so many of us think about this issue -- and more -- and I thank him for writing it. This whole issue would make a good story for “60 Minutes.”

Martha MuCullough
Buxton
 


I do not know Mike Berry, but I now consider him a friend. He makes the argument that the lawyers for the intervenors should have been allowed to make in court. Thank you, Mike. Thanks also to The Island Free Press for keeping us up to date on this mess.

Nathan Martin
Salisbury, N.C.

 
I am very disappointed with this whole situation. The Outer Banks is my favorite vacation spot. My family has enjoyed vacationing there for the past 10 years. I would even like to retire to the Outer Banks. If we are not allowed to access the shoreline by ORV we will be forced to find another place to vacation, and I will be looking for another place to spend my senior years.

Victor Martinson
Pitman, N.J.

 
Dr. Berry has clearly stated the facts of the matter concerning motorized beach access. With the queries raised by the judiciary today, it appears that the "powers that be" want to finish the job with permits, vehicle size, and beach population counts to further restrict the right of free and open beaches for the public use. Here we go, folks, now it is control by judicial fiat. Enjoy the beaches while you can. The day is rapidly approaching when the few enviro-nazis, leading their ignorant, would-be, do gooders will close the beaches for human use forever.
 
Dr Berry has talked about the rules and lack of candor involved in the lawsuit. I would like to ask about simple things such as honesty and honor. It is a poor example to our youth to have so-called serious negotiators make a promise and then have them turn around and break the very words that were solemnly given. The ends still do not justify the means and honor goes by the boards in actions such as these. Society suffers, and most importantly the youth see the actions of their elders and wonder to where the honesty has fled.
 
We should pursue this matter wherever possible, in Congress, in the courts of appeal and in the public forums, so that these hurtful restrictions are lifted and the will of the people be acknowledged by law.

Lawrence Cullen
Buxton

 
What Dr. Berry has written about makes me very angry. The plain fact that all the science (sic) from Audubon North Carolina is accepted as fact (which it is not) and now widely distributed and will be used to destroy other national seashores -- Cape Lookout and Assateague are two that come to mind -- is very troubling. This is a crime that needs to be brought to the light of day and the perpetrators punished by a court of law and rebuked by their peers. These perps should be drummed out of bird science and be jailed for crimes against humanity.

Jim Harris
Southern Shores




Fox on the beach


Kill the fox. They have overrun all areas. Nobody wants a fox coat anymore. They have no natural predators to keep their population in check.

Kurt Tribble
Millersville, Md.



Here is a picture of a fox and kit up north. I took this at 7a.m. in June.

The fox on the beach (at Cape Point) was probably a kit out on his own for the first time, looking for a meal, not bothered by humans because he sees them on the beach all the time and did not feel threatened. Foxes are on the beach in Brigantine, N.J., all the time early in the morning or late in the day when it is still very light out, and they will follow you up the beach keeping their distance, just being curious, never coming close enough to cause a threat. It is sickening what's going on down there. It's like throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I just do not get it.

Kathy Freeborn
West Grove, Pa.



I do not see this animal threatening anyone in these pictures. Abnormal behavior does not justify the public execution the fox. It certainly does not justify Barney Fife on the beach with a loaded shot gun and intent to kill. The park manager should be charged with animal cruelty and removed from the service. Any 6-year-old who has ever watched Animal Planet is screaming the question: Why did you have to kill the Fox?
Surely it could have been tranquilized, tested, and removed. If the service does not have a process in place to accomplish such a task, then the management needs to be replaced with someone who can get a plan in place. Bears are routinely removed from Yosemite and given a chance to live. They save alligators in Florida on a routine basis, but in the land of the piping plover, my tax dollars pay for some over-educated federal do-nothing to shoot an innocent fox in order to impress the eco-terrorist legal machine.
 
Does anyone remember the scene in the movie “Dances With Wolves” where the wolf is killed by the ignorant and cowardly soldiers?

Wes Hatter
Virginia Beach

 
It's extremely sad when officials feel they have to "protect" women and children from a fox minding its own business on the beach. The gun-toting officer hiding behind his car door looked a lot more dangerous, as well as ridiculous, to me. Let's get all fired up about our rights relative to driving on the beach, but just feel free to blow away native wildlife that might want to visit the shoreline as well.

Serena Barry
Richmond, Va.



Beach Access Issues

We have been coming to Avon and Rodanthe since 1983, and with no driving on the beach, my husband and I will find some place else to go fishing. It will only hurt OBX money wise. We spend over $3,000 every year there, and thousands of us do the same. Who wants to walk for miles to find a good fishing spot in deep sand and carry of the stuff for a day of fishing? The government must stay out of this or what’s left for us to do?

Judy Bragg
New Lebanon, Ohio

 
What is happening to our county, country, and world? With so may things wrong in so many places, our beaches are what these groups focus on. Where is the concern for children who have no medical care, go to bed hungry, live on the streets? The parents who have lost jobs because the company has moved overseas? Our military men and women fight everyday on foreign soil, spilling their blood, some never to return to loved ones, to protect our freedom! They are on foreign soil to give others a chance to have freedom, a democracy, and civil rights. We are the ancestors of many who have died on foreign soil to protect our freedom, democracy, and our civil rights. One of those rights is to have free and open access to one of God's greatest wonders.
 
My nephew, age 6, learned how to surf last summer along with his little friend.  They were taught by our local teens. It was an amazing sight to see them wax their short boards, strap the board to their ankles, and paddle out to catch a wave. What a blessing to see these two precious boys ride like the wind, and the pride on their faces was a blessing to us all.
 
The beach closure will affect every aspect of our lives, from the smallest to the oldest. Our ability to continue to make a living and provide medical care, food, and roof over our families will become more of a hardship than it is now. Our ancestors died and fought in all the previous wars trying to hold on to our democracy, freedom, and civil rights. One of those freedoms is to enjoy our beaches and  nature.

Rosa-Alice Mayo
Hatteras



First, I'd like to say that my group of fishermen is hesitant about renting a house this year until we are sure we can drive on the beach.  We usually come down from Philadelphia after Thanksgiving.  We rent in Frisco. Secondly, the Audubon Society and the other group pressing the lawsuit are a pack of liars.  They are not giving the true status of the piping plover. 

A few years ago I attended a reunion of my high school class in St. Louis.  A classmate is rather wealthy and owns a 5,000-acre hunt and fishing club north of St. Louis in the area of O'Fallon, Mo.  We were having our get together party at his clubhouse.  As I was talking with him in the parking area, we noticed a plover flitting around, and we realized she was protecting a nest in the gravel.  We put a fence around it to protect her eggs.  When I commented that the birds were endangered, he laughed and wanted to know where I had heard that.  When I told him about all the beach closings in New Jersey and Hatteras, he took me to the shore of the Quiver River where it empties into the Mississippi.  In no more than 200 yards, I saw at least 20 nesting pairs of piping plovers. A check of my Audubon book at home shows that the Mississippi Valley is the bird's main range, and that the East Coast is a minimal secondary area. 

They can close the beaches for the piping plover nesting areas for the next 100 years and still not have any more birds than there are now, and maybe even fewer depending on the weather.  And don't believe them when they say that those birds in Missouri are a different strain.

Dr. Richard E. McGirl
Philadelphia, Pa.

 
I have plans to come to the island the week of April 20 solely for surf fishing. I am in limbo. I have invested money in lodging. I have 10 buddies, all waiting for the answer with time running out. How can we be assured we will be able to surf fish. If they chose not to allow driving on the beach, will they force the businesses to refund my money?

Stuart Bush
Aylett, Va.
 

What a shame it would be to close ORV access to the beaches on the Outer Banks. I come down twice a year but will not make another trip if the beaches are closed. Even in Delaware now they rope off certain areas near the dunes to protect the birds, but at least we can still park and fish from the beach. Businesses will be hurt, as well as those who love the beach, fishing, surfing, and other activities. My thoughts and my heart are very sad that this may happen to such wonderful resources.

Art Abel
Wilmington, Del.



In response to the letter from P.A. Glass of Rodanthe:
 
You need to rethink why you live on Hatteras Island. I am sure that whatever you do to earn money will be affected if the beaches are closed.
 
"No matter what happens, people will always come to Hatteras and perhaps a few rules will bring a better quality visitor," you wrote. And what kind of visitors are you hoping for? A few rules?  I think closing our beaches doesn’t really constitute as a few rules.
 
Again, Mr. Glass, why is it you live here on Hatteras Island? Is it to call the locals fat, lazy, and ignorant? I think I speak for all locals when I say “thanks.” We really appreciate all the help and support you offer -- or don’t offer.

Mallory Gray
Buxton


 
As a resident of the Outer Banks and a mother of two small children, I think not allowing vehicles to drive on the beach would be devastating to our community in many ways. One of the biggest draws for my visiting and eventually moving here was having access to the beaches by vehicle. All of you Moms and Dads know what a pain it is to drag your gear out to the beach. It is near impossible for two adults to handle! I have lived in Kill Devil Hills and now Southern Shores for more than 11 years and, regardless of the convenience of the local beaches, I have always loaded my kids in our SUV with all of our "stuff" and driven south to either Oregon Inlet, Rodanthe (ramp 23), or the Point. We have spent almost all of our weekends in the summer there. If we loose that convenience, I won't be able to visit our beaches on a regular basis - way too much work! Honestly, if no driving on the beach is allowed here anymore, my family will be looking for a new place to live! Not only will it ruin our community with an unimaginable loss of revenue, but it will force many families to move because of lack of income. Others will leave just for the mere inability to access and enjoy what brought us here in the first place.

Nicole Bourne
Southern Shores
 


If beaches are closed to driving, my family will vacation elsewhere -- perhaps we will go out west. I love the ocean, and I love taking my mother, kids, grandkids, and this year, my son’s future in-laws to the Outer Banks. My two aunts and uncle usually rents a house the same time as we do. My girlfriend and her family will be renting a house in May, so we can vacation together. We love the Outer Banks, but if it is changed, then it will no longer have the same appeal. Leave it alone. If we wanted change, we could have booked a Grand Canyon vacation or headed to Myrtle Beach.

Tanya Wilcox
Circleville, Ohio



I continue to be amazed at the lack of truth being told by the ORV groups. I am on your side, but I also have read in detail all sides of this issue. It is not about our right to access the beach. The federal law creating the national park made the priorities to protect the natural resources. Just because the local NPS has not followed the law for over 35 years does not make this "a right" for us. Telling lies to the public is not helping our cause. break beak break

Mike Remi
Richmond, Va.

 
Now I know how my Native American ancestors felt when they saw their way of life disappearing before their eyes. Now I know how they felt when "the great white father in Washington " spoke to them "with a forked tongue.”

Kerry Hooper, Sr.
Avon


All of this nonsense regarding the Outer Banks is beyond being upsetting to me. The fact that the members of the Park Service have been allowed to collect paychecks that are drawn from taxes to fiddle with this since 1972 is absolutely unacceptable! How many Park Service employees have been dismissed from federal service for not performing in that aspect of their jobs? Last time I checked it was still the Cape Hatteras National Seashore AND RECREATION AREA. We have permitted four wheelers and dirt bikes in National Forests where access was once on foot or horseback. It seems there are only a few areas that remain accessible to me in Hatteras as I am getting older and less able to walk in soft sand. The beach will not magically get hard simply by removing vehicles, and I suspect the parking lots where there is walkover access will not grow.
I have read more "bad science" (phrased differently—“made up” facts to support a cause) regarding the adverse effects of ORVs than I can believe, and it just continues to show me that we as a society are either growing incredibly stupid, or apathetic. If the most obvious facts don't support a case, it seems acceptable to just make things up and use them in our judicial system. Why does it seem to me that more and more people who don't have a life feel that it is their new goal in life to keep others from enjoying themselves? It would be interesting to know how many of the people who would like to see access eliminated have ever spent a week visiting the areas that are currently limited to walk-in.

John Ellenberger
Monongahela, Pa.

 
I am saddened about what is happening at Cape Hatteras National Seashore. I listed to John Couch speak via the Internet, and he has said it so well. The National Seashore has failed to follow through with its responsibilities. I have been coming to the Outer Banks for over 39 years, so much that it is home to me more than Maryland ever will be. I will support the coalition in fighting the fight with all Outer Bankers. You can be sure of that!

Stephanie Ryder
Boonsboro, Md.

 
My family and I have visited Ocracoke at least twice a year for the past 33 years. We come for the freedom of driving on the beach, to pick your very own spot to fish and relax. We will not make the nine-hour trip if we can't drive on the beach, especially South Point and Hatteras. Why take away the most beautiful spot in the USA? Please let me know if I can help stop this nonsense.

Amber Hill
Pilot Mountain, N.C.

 
Thanks to Kate and Daniel Pullen for putting this article about surfers' concerns about beach access together. I first discovered Hatteras 25 years ago because of surfing, and continue to visit and surf there.

It's extremely rare to find any surfer who hasn't made it a priority to visit Hatteras for the unspoiled beauty and free access to the ocean and beaches. Most surfers care about birds, turtles, and fish. However, we also care about cats! We also care about having a safe bridge! We like freedom and liberty too, like being American and having the right to enjoy our natural environment. It's a sure bet that many surfers give to environmental groups out of concern for the natural earth and all its creatures. We need to stop supporting these groups. Defenders of Wildlife? More like attackers of human life! Southern Environmental Law? That isn’t any southern hospitality I'm familiar with, and my point is that their law is unjust. They are begging us to fight with civil disobedience, since their argument is so blatantly wrong we'd be wasting our time to even argue. Birds and turtles are important, but so are cats and people. Killing the cats and removing the people won't save any bird. Only God decides these matters.

Groups of non-local, self-righteous political activists with money are wrong to play God, deciding a bird is more important than a cat, or a person for that matter. All the people in power need to know is that this land was bequeathed to us for our enjoyment, and no outsiders have any right to take it away.

Michael Letso
Chadwick Beach, N.J.

 
Kudos to Daniel and Kate Pullen for the article on surfers involvement in helping to prevent the elimination of ORV beach access. Hope the ramp is still open when I get home.  Thank you for staying involved.

Jeffrey Del Monte
Buxton (currently in Iraq)


The National Park System Act of 1916 carries with it the mandate to preserve resources for the enjoyment of the people and yet leave resources unimpaired for future generations. I would call this a balance.
  
People have been driving on the beaches of North Carolina almost since the automobile was invented without impacting birds or sea turtles for two -- maybe more -- generations, which tells me the current system has been working fine. Closing these beaches to ORV traffic would be no different than closing Yellowstone or any other national park to public traffic. If the people cannot enjoy these resources, which by the way we the people own, why have a park system?

The NPS has been working with locals to find common goal, which all parties can live with, to include the local economy. The extreme environmentalists don’t want to work with anybody. They just want to close the beaches for a bird that is at the most southern extreme of its habitat. Common sense would dictate this is probably why there have only been one or two breeding pairs in the Hatteras area for as long as anyone can remember. These birds seem to be doing just fine farther north, which is a pretty good indicator that the ones coming down to Hatteras aren’t going to be multiplying in any significant numbers and just maybe out of touch with their species.
 
For quite a few years, I have been coming down to the Outer Banks. so I can drive on the beaches to enjoy the ocean and the environment.  I spend thousands of dollars every year on the local economy. If the beaches are closed to ORVs, there is no reason for me and thousands of others to drive down to the OBX and spend our money. There are plenty of other beaches closer that I can park in a parking lot and walk to a crowded beach.
Closing these beaches to thousands of ORVs will devastate the local economy.
That brings me North Carolina’s Gov. Mike Easley, and Sen. Elizabeth Dole, both of whom have shown very little interest in this matter. Makes one wonder to whom their allegiances are. It sure does appear to be to the economic well being of the people of Dare and Hyde counties.

Stephen  Andrews
Rixeyville, Va.


 
Great job Kate Pullen and Island Free Press! Also, a big hand to Brett and Casey. This is a very special island and we need everyone at every age to stand and fight now! The solution will not come overnight, so don't give up. It's just like paddling out: how bad do you really want it?

Kevin McCabe
Buxton

 

Our national seashore access is imminently threatened with being altered without the benefit of the democratic process.  The enabling legislation is being violated by a renegade judge.

My wife and I own two rental properties on Cape Hatteras, one in Frisco (which we will use when it isn't rented) and one in Hatteras (for investment). I am also a member of my local Environmental Commission, and, until being made aware of the pending situation, was a member of Audubon and Defenders of Wildlife.
 
Having established my environmentalism, let me say that I am one "tree-hugger" who thinks the draconian closing of the beaches to ORVs is insane, for all the reasons cited in your article: the government's bureaucratic bungling, the islands' traditions, and the calamity it would create economically. I've been coming to Cape Hatteras at least annually since the mid-1970s, and have good friends among the year-round residents. As well as financially, this closure will affect all of us spiritually and emotionally.
 
For our part, my wife and I have cancelled our Audubon and Defenders memberships (and told them why), signed the Save Hatteras "PleaCast," and written to our local senators and congressman to urge a congressional intervention to stop this insanity. I urge anyone with an interest in Cape Hatteras to do the same.
 
We do not condone rude and illegal driving, littering or other anti-environmental activities whether on or off the beach, but Judge Boyle's decision does nothing except create ill will and economic hardship. We are disgusted and disheartened by the unilateral imposition of his "remedy," which is totally inappropriate for the issues it is supposed to resolve - "issues" which, themselves, are open to serious question - and we hope and pray that sanity will find a foothold and put an end to this abuse of judicial power.

Paul Payton
Chatham, N.J.

 

I live in Walnut Cove, N.C., and I wonder if anyone has taken into consideration the effects that this could have on the economies to cities that are not even on the coast. I have a cousin that owns a tackle shop in Walnut Cove, and a lot of his customers purchase a lot of items from him for fishing on the Outer Banks. So the damage to people’s livelihood extends out much further than just on the coast. I personally will hate to have to find another place to vacation with my family and fish because I truly love the island and all that it has to offer.

Billy Bingman
Walnut Cove, N.C.


 
Another way to handle this issue is to line up the Defenders of Wildlife and Audubon on one side and the lifetime residents and property owners on the other side at Hatteras Point, and we can all just have a good old throw down. Last man standing decides the fate of the beaches! We don't need the government to decide this one!

Bruce McCrickard
Suffolk, Va.

 

I've been heading south for vacations and peace of mind for almost 40 years. I simply cannot imagine the beaches of my childhood and my children's to be closed down. The economy of the Outer Banks is so dependent on the beaches that to shut them down without any access would mean the end for many people's livelihoods. There has to be some kind of compromise made that would protect the birds and turtles, while also allowing humans access to the beaches. May common sense prevail in the upcoming weeks to develop a plan that protects the way of life for animals and man alike.

Kate Musick
Gloucester, Va.

 
It seems to me the National Park Service already has an ORV Plan: Beach access only at designated ramps, beach speed limit, wildlife enclosures ever changing and added where deemed necessary, seasonal changes in the open beach, no driving on the dunes, driving only where directed by The Park Service, dogs on leashes, plus all the other rules and regulations. Cannot this all be designated our official ORV Plan?

I have always felt grateful to the NPS for preserving our beaches. We have all seen the occasional knucklehead out there roaming around, but I hope that the Park Service and the environmental groups realize that the biggest majority of ORV users want to protect the beaches and respect all the enclosures and the rules and regulations.

Susan Wyche
Frisco

 

We have been coming with my family to Hatteras since the late 1970's. My father heard about this wonderful fishing island that you can drive right out on the beach to this place called the Point and get the best fishing of anywhere in North America. With such excitement and anticipation, little money, and an old pickup with a camper, he headed out. "What a place,” he said. We all fell in love with Hatteras Island and the local people who live there. They have become our family. We have been coming ever since. My father has since passed, but every year my mom, my sister’s family, and our family visit and stay on the island. This is the only place I can come and still see my dad sitting in his chair, with his fishing hat, pole, and the old green truck parked right beside him on the beach at the Point. My husband and brother-in-law continue the tradition of fishing. We now see two pickup trucks on the beach, and if we look real closely, we can see three chairs setting in the sand.

Hatteras Island and the all of our local family who live there stand to loose a great deal if we let them take the island. We understand about the wildlife and will do what we can to help protect it, but this cannot be all one sided. What do these groups plan to do about the wildlife up in Nags Head? Get rid of all the people? Technically speaking, if they win, that is what will happen on Hatteras Island.

Theresa Reiff
Waynesboro, Pa.



I was not aware of these beach access issues until Wednesday, two days before the scheduled hearing on April 4, when I received an email from Midgett Realty asking for support. I faxed that same day both my two senators and representative here in Pennsylvania, asking for their support/action. Thank you, Judge Boyle, for granting a continuance and looking at both sides of the issue. As one person stated during this turbulent time, humans are part of nature.

We have vacationed for many years now on Hatteras Island. I believe last spring, there were already areas at the Point cordoned off for the wildlife. The wildlife issues have not been ignored! We even came down a second time in September last year and went to the beach at Billy Mitchell. I was surprised at how many people braved the winds (the hovering offshore tropical storm had moved further away) to enjoy the beach. To all involved in negotiations, please remember the handicapped, elderly, fishermen, surfers, young, etc., when you attempt to reach an agreement. To all realtors,  please reach out to your renters for support if you have not done so. This is far more than a local or even state issue. We are behind you -- even us Yankees!

Shirley Miller
Sellersville, Pa.


 
I hope the beaches remain open. My family and I have traveled the Outer Banks for 40-plus years. We have driven on the beach all of these years, and now my children are getting to experience driving on the open beach and enjoying the non-commercial way of life. It is such a wonderful time for peace and relaxation in such a wonderful place God has created. I like for my children to experience the simple things, and one day maybe my grandchildren will be able to do the same.

Rita W. Hooper
Clyde, N.C.



I packed my truck last night. This morning, my family and I will drive 12 hours to Cape Hatteras. We have been visiting Hatteras since the early ‘70s. What I have always loved about the Outer Banks is that I could do any thing there. My father shared his love of the ocean, sound, and marshes that are the cape’s barrier islands. My father is now retired to Cape Cod. I now live and work on Long Island. While we live in places that are similar to Cape Hatteras, they are still not that wonderfully special place where I learned how to play with its forces – wind, waves, and water – and to feed from its bounty – fish, crabs, and shellfish -- and stand in awe of its beauty. That’s why we keep coming back.
 
But if you ban four-wheel-drive access, you will make it impossible for me to share the same experience with my family that my father shared with me. Sure, you may need to limit or regulate ORV access. There are just too many SUVs around today. But an outright ban is unnecessary! There are just too many of us who use four-by-four access responsibly who will be hurt in the process. We understand that the beach is a fragile and ever changing place, best accessed by foot, or by responsible four-wheel access. The last thing you want is hard structures like roads and parking lots.
 
So, I will make my “pilgrimage” to the OBX today. I’ve already paid for my rental house. Because of this love for the Cape, we visit in the spring or fall. Any sunburned tourist can love the Cape in the summer…But we rent homes and spend dollars when it is 50 degrees, 40 knots, and pouring rain. And we love it! Take away our access and see how many of us show up next season.

Frank Messina
Port Washington, N.Y.


 
We own property in Frisco, and my family (Sawyer) originated from this area dating back to the 1700s. Thanks for working so hard to keep a tradition that has made Hatteras what it is today. Man and nature belong together. We love it and respect it.

Renee Bradshaw
Virginia Beach

 

Loss of beach access would ruin the special feeling of remoteness and uncrowdedness that Hatteras Island has offered my family and friends. The summer vacations we have enjoyed for years would come to an end. I am getting to old to lug chairs, coolers, and umbrellas the distance it would take to capture the memories and special family times we have had for so many years. There are many crowded beaches closer to home. Please do not let this happen.

Philip Crow
Pittsburgh, Pa.


 
To Ms. Thibodeau of Connecticut (Letters, April 1):
 
Please understand, by shutting down the beaches to user groups, we are doomed to become another Myrtle Beach. If you can't go to the beach, who's going to provide the experience at Hatteras? It will be your new friends at Hooters, Wings, Lucky's Pool Hall, Beach Babes, Gentleman's Club, etc. because the families that built us will be forced to abandon us. As a result, there will be a new type of visitor as we become like, well, everyone else, including Myrtle Beach.

Danny Couch
Buxton


 
I am not a surfer, or fisherman, or a tourist. I am a local who loves the beach. Our summers will be destroyed, as well as our economy. I think (surfer) Jason Andre from Buxton summed it up best, "...but it needs to be done like most things, in hearts, minds, and spirits of individuals empowered through love, education, and action not through litigation, legislation, and bureaucracy." I hope this message reaches all locals concerned in this situation.

Kristin Tomlin
Elizabeth City

 

How ironic that those ancestors of mine who saved thousands of lives by roaming the beaches in all kinds of weather would no longer be allowed to scour the ocean for victims in this day and age. Let's not even mention that those beaches belonged to those ancestors before they reluctantly allowed the federal government to buy them cheap for the public to use. The definition of public lately seems to have changed to birds and turtles only.

Miles Midgette
Salvo and Colington



And more letters

Letters in support of beach access also came from these writers, who remembered 20 or 30 or 40 years of visiting Hatteras and driving on the beaches and thanked the people who are leading the fight to keep beaches open:

John W. Johnson, Suffolk, Va.
Bob and Bev Walker, Pleasant Gap, Pa.
Sharon Yancey, Midlothian, Va.
Walker Family, Butler, Pa.
Brian Forney, Waynesboro, Pa.
David Hamilton, Shelter Island, N.Y.
Chris Figiel, Hopewell, Va.
Bryant H. Champagne
David Monte, Kitty Hawk
Alisia Mitchell, Powell, Ohio
Sam Krohn, Salisbury, N.C.
Deborah Mann, Suffolk, Va.
Shirley Beard, Colonial Heights, Va.
Paul Scrutton, Durham, N.C.
Stephen Smith, Forest Hill, Md.
Loren Albertson. Elizabeth City
Terri Harris, Williamsburg, Va.
Rob Lubas, Annandale, Va.
Laura Depew, Murrysville, Pa.




Please let me know how I can help in this fight. I have a daughter with cerebral palsy who, in the absence of ORV access, would be unable to enjoy the beaches of the Outer Banks.
 
As a longtime vacationer to Hatteras Island, this is very disturbing. These extremist environmental groups have no regard for the financial well-being of the small businesses on the island or the quality of life of the human beings on the island.
 
Shawn Turschak
Chapel Hill, N.C.

 
This agreement, in my opinion, has been one-sided, favoring a group of individuals who have an agenda other than protecting sea turtles and piping plovers. I have been a North Carolina resident for the majority of my life (since the ‘70s) and have enjoyed the Outer Banks. I can attest to the fact the adverse impact on endangered species as a result of ORV's has been inconsequential. I request the interim plan be contested, as well as the final ORV management plan be reviewed and approved by an institution, which is experienced in game and wildlife preservation, not the Audubon Society. How can Judge Boyle be so short sighted?

Glenn Vick
Greensboro, N.C.


We have lost the battle but not the war.

William Old
Hatteras

 
It is repulsive to me that the SELC's attorney fees will be paid, essentially, by citizen tax revenues. I feel sorry for the rank and file members of the Audubon Society, given the incompetence on public display by its leadership and the bullying influence exerted over them by the SELC and Defenders of Wildlife. I think every estate planner and benefactor ought to be given a primer on personal agendas and anti-social zealots that can and do mismanage their contributions. I will never be able to look at these people the same way again.

Danny Couch
Buxton

 
Because I've already paid, this will be my last year staying in Avon. Otherwise, I wouldn't be back this year.

David F. Smith
Lynchburg, Va.
 

Sadly, it appears to be an end of a 20-year era of our lives with the recent settlement. No point in traveling 11 hours when we have a state full of inaccessible shoreline and unreasonable public land restrictions right here at home. Once it starts, it doesn't end until all is lost. We have first hand experience of that.
 
This will undoubtedly have a devastating effect on the economy on the islands. And I feel sorry for the Park Service for the incredible burden that this will place on them -- not a job that any of them studied and trained for.
 
Our future vacations will focus on New Hampshire, where the license plates read "Live free or Die." This sort of thing would never go there.

Ed Chepan
Burlington, Conn.

 
I appreciate your coverage of this whole matter. I love being able to drive on the beaches for fishing and for family fun with my wife and kids. If we are lucky, maybe someone will import a bunch of raccoons to destroy the bird nests and eggs.

Chris Shelburne
Chesapeake, Va.


Terrence W. Boyle is absolutely the worst judicial recommendation that former U. S. Sen. Jesse Helms ever made. Helms tapped Boyle for a U. S. district judgeship as a favor to the senator's long-time campaign manager, Raleigh attorney Tom Ellis, Boyle's father-in-law.

A New Jersey native and Ivy League Brown University graduate, Boyle does not know diddly-squat about mobile surf fishing or the wildlife at the Cape Hatteras National Recreational Seashore. It's highly doubtful that Hizonner has ever driven an ORV on the beach or held a surf rod in his hand. Yet with one stroke of his arrogant pen, a man who doesn't know a circle hook from a doughnut hole has placed himself in charge of the entire CHNRS in blessing a private negotiation process which took place behind closed doors with no public input or comment.

Few know it, but Boyle has a hidden political agenda. He wants desperately to be elevated to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals in Richmond.  His previous nominations to this court have been stymied by the Democrats on the Senate Judiciary Committee, led by Sen. Joseph Biden of Delaware. What better way for Boyle to curry favor with his opponents than to bless a consent decree advocated by liberal environmentalist elements that compose a major Democrat Party interest group?
 
Boyle's handling of this lawsuit and settlement smacks of judicial tyranny and personal, political aggrandizement of the worst sort.
 
William I. Berryhill, Jr.
Chief United States Marshal, Ret.
Eastern District of North Carolina
(Appointed by President Ronald Reagan)
Raleigh, N.C.


 
Last year, our state imposed a state saltwater fishing license, which I purchased – a life-time license. I did so with the hopes that maybe some of that money would be used to further improve and protect the resource. That license grants me the right to fish in our ocean and estuaries, but if the agenda of these out of state special interest groups is successful many of my favorite fishing spots will be inaccessible. It would only be fair to have the license fee refunded.

Philip Smith
Winston-Salem, N.C.

 
The federal defendants, delinquently lacking a plan, are the vanquished, and will pay the legal fees with our tax dollars. But they sustain no other losses. The intervenor –defendants -- local or distant, resident or visitor, sportsmen or beachgoers -- will be the punished. And by implication they are to be held responsible for any deliberate violations, no matter by whom, with resultant escalating restrictions. This is reminiscent of the dealing with resistance forces in another time and place.
What have we come to?

Fred Westervelt
Ocracoke

 
Even though I am an avid birdwatcher, I think that this is outrageous that they would close the beaches or not allow vehicles or people on the beaches in the Outer Banks! I go to the Outer Banks to fish and enjoy the ambience there. It is a shame if they allow these birds to take over and ruin many businesses and close down the Outer Banks to vacationer or fishermen or fisherwomen. All the years I have been there, no one has harmed or hurt the birds, and everyone has been on their best behavior and following the rules. Never have I ever thought that I would not be allowed to go to the beaches. And I am disabled too, so I could never walk the beaches.  Please take into account that many people count on these beaches being open. The beaches should be free for everyone to use.

Cristine Boehringer
Lake Wylie, S.C.


Defenders of Wildlife, Southern Environmental Law Center, and the Audubon Society are the same parties that sued the Navy over the outlying landing field. And Judge Boyle was the same judge.

Will Noble
Norfolk, Va.

 
I am glad a settlement has been reached. It is clearly a one-sided settlement that favors the environmental groups. The environmental groups took advantage of the situation. There is sure to be backlash from the agreement. I personally plan to get involved and pledge resources to ensure that the rights of the public are preserved.

David Crews
Raleigh, N.C.

 
While I understand and appreciate the value of wildlife, I also feel a more equitable solution could have been reached. As someone who spends more than $5,000 annually each year in Hatteras, I can say without bias that the night-time restrictions and other measures in place will result in my family spending our time and money elsewhere. It is a true shame to see a paradise taken out of the hands of those who have supported it financially. Don't take my word on it -- ask the local businesses how things are during the next three years (if you can find any who remain in business).

Jim Stanley
Midlothian, Va.


 
This is to my fellow North Carolinians of the Outer Banks.
 
On this day, my two young sons and I are greatly saddened to learn of the bad news that Judge Boyle and the federal government have handed down to us. My youngest is 10 and my oldest is 15, and luckily for them, we have camped and fished for three straight years on Hatteras and Ocracoke islands. To think my two sons could never take their own children is something I never thought I would have to worry about. I was wrong.
 
I joined the N.C. Beach Buggy Association several years ago and began to frequent many Web sites that were forwarded to me and all other sportsmen and beach lovers alike that said this turf war was on the horizon, and it wasn’t going to be pretty. I also began to write letters to my congressman and the Park Service and prompted others to do so. Frank and Fran’s, Red Drum Tackle, and PierandSurf.com were among the many sites that did a great job keeping us all abreast of these things.
 
I'm afraid we are all to blame for this and bear a bit of the burden for not doing enough, but I realize some good people did all they could, and for that I am grateful. I wish to say thank you for your efforts. I will continue to support the local economy on the islands by bringing my sons down to "our" beloved Outer Banks as long as Highway 12 is open. The islanders need our support now more than they ever did! Do not quit coming to the Outer Banks!
 
I feel deep sorrow for the hard-working people on the islands whose way of life is under attack. The way I see it, they were not counted as one of God's viable creatures that is also worth "preserving." When you start putting birds and turtles over people, I believe someone has their priorities mixed up. One judge played God, but he is not God. He made a mistake and now many innocent people will suffer from it. This has nothing to do with fishing or ORVs on the beach!
 
It is my firm belief that God put the forests and its trees, plants, animals, beaches, and creatures of the sea all here for our responsible use. In the many years (12) I've fished Hatteras and Ocracoke islands, I have yet to see a single abuse of the resources we all love and respect. If anything, fishermen have always stood up and asked others to "do the right thing" while enjoying the Outer Banks by picking up trash, treading lightly, and using good ethics while utilizing the great outdoors.
 
There are always a few "bad apples" in society, and unfortunately for the majority of good people that are also sportsmen, the special interest groups will always point to the most egregious acts they can find and implicate all to justify their means to end all they see fit to end. Folks, it just doesn’t make any sense.

When will people learn that conservationists can also be preservationists? The big money may have won this initial battle, but I feel this fight has just begun. North Carolinians are known for their good common sense and their willingness to stand up and fight for a just cause, and it is high time we start acting like it. Support your fellow North Carolinians who live on the Outer Banks! They too are an endangered species!
 
God bless the Outer Banks and its people!
 
Greg Williams
Eagle Spring, N.C.

 
We have been coming to Hatteras Island to fish and swim for many years. We have enjoyed these occasions, and would like our grandchildren to have the same advantages that we have. We are careful around the nesting bird areas and do not disturb them. We take our trash and litter and leave the beach just as we found it. At our age, to park on the street and walk over the dunes and down to the ocean is beyond our physical strength, especially if you’re carrying chairs, picnic items, children’s toys, and fishing gear. If we no longer are able to use the beach, we will have to find a place that can allow us to use their facilities. This will mean fewer visitors to the beach area, closing of shops and restaurants, and fewer rentals, and vacationers, and, of course, fewer tax dollars for the state of North Carolina. I am an environmental person but believe that this federal land is also for our use, not just the nesting birds. And as a tax-paying citizen, I should have the right to use it whenever I wish. As you know, in government once something is closed or taken over it’s never opened back up again. I think Hatteras and the people there will suffer terribly if this ban goes into place.

Please keep the beach open. It belongs to everyone to enjoy. Our children need to see, know, and learn to respect nature, just as we did. Teaching them to fish or hunt seashells and keeping them together as a family may also help when they get older and have more serious things develop in their lives. Keep the beach open for everyone’s pleasure. Please.

Linda Graham
Clarks Hill, S.C.

 
I feel for you business owners on the Outer Banks. But I can't spend my vacation time at a place without ORV access to the points. I was planning a trip for the month of May. Maybe next year if this situation is improved. Yes, I did write my senators and congressman.

Baxter Shelton
Kannapolis, N.C.
 
The environmentalists do not care to share nature. They think that only animals should be able to enjoy nature. Every time they sue to stop humans from enjoying nature, the humans lose. It is a shame that they are going to stop a huge amount of folks from coming down to North Carolina. In all the years I have been going down to the Outer Banks fishing, I have never seen a bird nest in the sand at the tide line. I have never seen a vehicle driving in the grassy dunes. I think we should share the environment, but not be dominated by the environmentalists. The fishermen do not fish in the dunes. They fish in the water. The birds nest in the dune and grassy areas. It is a shame that an entire economy is going to fail because the good fishing areas are going to be closed off. The six to 20 piping plovers that may or may not inhabit the 60 to 100 miles of shoreline in the Outer Banks are just the excuse the environmentalists are using to stop vehicular traffic on the seashore.

David Southall
Charlottesville, Va.

 
In all the years my family has visited since 1967, we have been impressed with the regard for the use of the national recreation area by the folk who live and work there. Their needs and desires are not reflected in the "behind closed doors" decisions agreed to by the legal combatants focused on a rare bird's welfare. Of no consequence are the returning visitors or the permanent residents who need to have access to the "prime" areas closed off.

We have here the best example of what caring, responsible users of the area do not need  or want -- that is bureaucrats and lawyers deciding in closed rooms the use of public areas that are funded by all of us.

Thought: Does the mismanagement of use "break" the original agreement between the Park Service and the landowners? It should.

Robert Walker
Pleasant Gap, Pa.

 
The extremists won. The so-called negotiation has effectively closed down Hatteras Island beach access to everyone but oceanfront property owners.

Robert Leh
Easton, Pa.

 
I have read the consent decree, and I absolutely disagree with all aspects of it. I had rather withhold approval, as a resident/fisherman, than accept this document as written. Who says we have to accept it as the Defenders of Wildlife have written it because it's obvious no resident had any input.

Billy E. Norrell
Avon

 
Well, here it is. The consent decree "negotiated" behind closed doors, out of view of the public. Where are we? China? What happened to transparency? What happened to the democratic process? I'll tell you what happened. "The Three" -- Audubon, DOW, and SELC -- hijacked the process. That's what happened! These folks were a part of negotiated rulemaking, but decided to pursue their own agenda in federal court, and they won. The judge agreed to let our attorneys into the negotiation only after a lengthy debate and after he basically told the other side that they won. The motion our attorneys made to present evidence was only granted after our contingent walked out on negotiations last Friday. It sure would have been nice to have that presented during the proceedings. This consent decree makes me sick!

There are too many requirements heaped on the National Park Service. I don't know how they will provide enough funding or manpower to do 1/2 of what is required in the consent decree. The automatic expansions of the "buffer" areas will simply lead to the same closures they were pursuing from the beginning. What will stop "the Three" from sending one of their minions to breach a closure and have the expansion kick in? Soon enough, it will all be closed anyway. The hotline is a joke. Who's going to call and bring forth punishment to all for the actions of one? I simply can't believe that "the Three" will be compensated for their legal fees! There would be no legal fees if they had simply stayed with the negotiated rulemaking process until its completion, like they promised to do before being allowed to sit on the committee in the first place.

I say kick "the Three" off negotiated rulemaking, continue with the process as expeditiously as possible, and let's get rid of this consent decree as soon as possible!

Mike Stokes
Kill Devil Hills

 
For the last 20 years, I have brought my family to the Banks, typically twice a year. One of the most important activities that drew us there was night fishing at the Point. This decree effectively eliminates beach driving. Don't believe that? Watch and learn. I will no longer be vacationing and spending money in Dare County, effective immediately. That includes canceling a trip planned for next month (May). I feel sorry for those residents of the villages in the park who have consistently opposed limitations on beach driving because they understood that the activity contributed to their livelihood. For this ban to be imposed in conjunction with the housing bubble collapse, the recession, and dramatically increasing gas prices portends some very hard times ahead in those villages.

As for the locals who decided that their interests were better served by cozying up to the Feds and the bird-brains, I have no sympathy.- I sincerely hope that there is a personal bankruptcy filing in their near-term future.

Roland Deschain
Chesapeake City, Md.

 
Being a preservationist myself, I can appreciate the efforts to preserve wildlife areas. But let us not forget that recreational activities alleviate stress, bring joy to families, and build stronger communities. These beaches are enjoyed by hard-working, tax-paying citizens who may in the future, as the bird population grows to what levels, must sacrifice their beaches to birds.
 
What is your limit and what rights are these organizations opening themselves up to liability for suits like, damage to income for local citizens who depend on tourism or other organizations with beach access interests.
 
Let’s not lose wildlife sanctuaries, but let us not loose that which we all look forward to -- a chance to enjoy our beaches. Please beware of how far this goes.
 
Daniel Miller
Unionville, Va.

 
I just feel sick now. They have really taken this too far. I just would rather bulldoze the whole OBX if it is going to be this way.

Mike Cook
Asheville, N.C.

 

I have totally enjoyed the seashore for 34 years. Would love, more than anything (except my wife, of course), to live there. I have not given up on that idea/plan yet, but do wish I had "bit-the-bullet" 10 years ago. The dollar cost would have been more reasonable. I was born in North Carolina and fully intend to go back to die. My very first trip to the seashore was thanks to my parents, Mr. and Mrs. Earl Fountain, Back Swamp, N.C., around 1960 or so, complete with pictures made by a Kodak Brownie. Since '74, I have been as few as once, but as many as six times a year. There simply is no other place I'd rather be.

Travis Fountain
Aiken, S.C.

 
After last week's agreement, I had become at least hopeful. However, after reading this article (about judge seeks more information), it feels as though we're back at square one. This does not sound good at all. It seems as though this judge has had it out for us from day one. He's requesting everything that we had feared the most. I'm very worried at this point.

Angel Herrell
Virginia Beach

 
I was part of the original efforts in the early 1970s to establish ORV rules for Cape Cod, Assateague, and Cape Hatteras national seashores. We even had a four-by-four parade of several hundred vehicles down Pennsylvania Avenue and parked in front of the White House. It's a shame that no one from Park Service followed through 35-plus years ago to make sure the rules were published in the Federal Register. Perhaps we dropped the ball somewhat too. Anyhow, thanks for all your efforts to keep our beaches open.

Frank A. Jakob
Salvo
 

I am no lawyer, but it seems to me when the Park Service promised they would never stop beach driving, this would be an oral contract. Also this promise was published in the The Coastland Times – a written contract? I was at these meetings in the ‘50s and heard first hand.

Carol Dillon
Buxton

 
If I am reading the maps correctly, this compromise, while assuredly not totally satisfactory to all parties on both sides, would seem to provide a reasonable point of departure. As always reading the decree, with the “if” and “then” confirms that the devil will be in the details.

Craig Lugart
Fairfax, Va.

 
It's disturbing that an activity (ORV driving) is declared illegal because our government didn't give us specific permission to do it. That's backwards from the Constitution and most principles of freedom, which generally state that activities are legal until specifically prohibited.
 
After visiting Hatteras Island for over 20 years, my wife and I have been considering buying a beach house there. This court issue is causing me to have grave doubts about a purchase now. It sounds like the random motions of a chick will dictate the value of my property and where I can access the ocean on a daily basis.

Ken Kellar
Woodsboro, Md.
 
 
 
This is a stupid plan, and I don't understand why anyone who values the heritage and traditions of the people of this area would agree to this garbage. The NPS pledged unfettered access to the beaches when they confiscated this land from the rightful owners. It is the Cape Hatteras National Seashore RECREATION Area - not a wildlife preserve. We have a huge wildlife preserve at Pea Island and de facto wildlife preserves on Portsmouth Island and the islands in the Pamlico Sound. Audubon and Defenders of Wildlife have greatly dishonored themselves by breaking their pledge to negotiate in good faith in the negotiated rulemaking process. Furthermore, they have dishonored themselves by embracing junk science of the worst kind. The people of the communities of the lower Outer Banks need to vehemently protest this plan and get sustained national exposure to the injustices thrust upon this community by a group of environmental extremists and an all too willing federal judge. Judge Boyle has demonstrated a clear bias in his rulings thus far. The court did not recognize the original promises made to this community by the NPS, nor did they acknowledge that the community has an over-riding cultural and economic interest in assuring access. Instead, this was a behind-closed-doors settlement that totally ignored the needs of the people who have lived here for many generations. This whole process reeks and must be subjected to judicial review and moved out of the District Court and Judge Boyle's biased view.

Here are some key questions that no one on the Plaintiffs side or the court seems to want to face.

1. Why is the piping plover considered a threatened species, and how was that determination made?
2. Why are the beaches of North Carolina considered critical habitat when Audubon's own manual indicates that the piping plover does not normally nest on this coast and only rarely winters on this coast?
3. Where is the proof that any piping plover has been harmed by an ORV, or by any human?
4. Is there any solid science to support Audubon's position?
5. Why has the court refused to consider the economic impact of these beach closures?
6. What really happened to the original ORV plan that decades ago was agreed upon by the NPS, the communities affected, and the user groups?
7. Why have the elected federal representatives of these communities not taken effective action to override this injustice from an unelected federal district judge and a group of environmental extremists?

Carolyn Neal
Hatteras

 
As a long-time visitor to the Outer Banks, I am deeply distressed by what has happened in my favorite vacation destination. Surf fishing is my greatest reason for visiting the area -- lots of beaches to choose from with good access, year-round opportunities to catch a variety of species, plenty to occupy the rest of the family. I will find other areas to fish, but what of the people who live there and depend on the money I bring for their livelihoods? With many small businesses already having problems, this could ruin the economy and cause a lot more damage than vehicles on the beach ever could.
I wonder what the birdwatchers will think when they discover their favorite motel or restaurant has closed because the surf fishing crowd has gone elsewhere? I also wonder where they think the money to manage the resource is going to come from?

Mark Mason
Newport News, Va.

 
 
I surf fish down here in Louisiana and catch my share of bull reds every year, but have watched this case closely because I always wanted to make it to Cape Hatteras after hearing about it in 1971 while in D.C. Twenty years of military service plus 17 of other work after that delayed that possibility. Well, I guess Judge Boyle has ended that dream! That man is either in someone's pocket or is just one sick puppy! My feelings go out to all on Ocracoke.

Walt Thompson
Pineville, La.

 
The safest place for mothers with small children to bathe is in the shallow tidal pools that develop near low tide just east of Hatteras Inlet. Under this consent decree that place is closed. Thank you, Judge, for taking care of the birds and to heck with the safety of our precious children!

Bob Davis
Buxton

 
My family has vacationed in Hatteras every year for the last 26. We love wildlife and the ocean. Our children and the friends we have included over the last 26 years still go with us and now bring their families. We have never caused destruction to the beach or to any of the bird, turtles, etc. Our goal is to enjoy everything Hatteras has to offer. For this group to assume that by our driving on the beach we are hurting any of the natural creatures there is foolish. If these folks have that much extra time, maybe they should be protecting our borders instead of our beaches.

Roxianne Parrish
King William, Va.


We have used the Outer Banks as our main getaway for the last 35 years, with the most wonderful time spent on the beach fishing with our four-wheel vehicles. I have never seen a bird killed by a vehicle. In fact, they seemed to enjoy the scraps of bait and seaweed that we left for the birds. I think these people forget that we are a part of nature too, and we have seen that the interaction that occurs with the other animals etc. is as natural as nature itself. This area is precious to everyone who has used it for all the years, so regulate the crazies with a little more policing, but don't ruin this area for everyone, and that is what's being done. I can only send my sympathies to the people who live on the Outer Banks and make their living there. All of us are losing with this kind of settlement.

Daniel Hall
Yorktown, Va.

 
This settlement truly breaks my heart and all of my family's as well. Going down to The beach is key to keeping my sanity throughout the "work year." What do these Big 3 think will happen to North Carolina’s economy? Don’t they realize what happens in one part of the state eventually affects the whole? How many visitors stop in other parts of the state to get to the beach? I believe the decision was very one-sided and is certain to cause long term hurt and loss to one of the most beautiful and laid-back places on Earth.

Jill Marshall
Ashland, Va.
 

I did a little research of my own and found all of the species (gull billed tern, black skimmer, common tern, least tern, and American oystercatcher) that special interest groups claim are decreasing have been going up and down for the last 40 years. The biggest impact that was placed on the birds was in the early 1900s because of people collecting eggs. How can they file a lawsuit using invalid data? I found most of my data on the USGS Web site. Does the word "perjury" mean anything to them?

Forrest Pace
Clayton, N.C.

 
A thread to Chris Canfield, Audubon Society representative in Richmond, Va. Feel free to forward or post.

Chris, to repeat what I said in my message to you.  There are thousands and thousands of acres for birds to nest on the Atlantic coast. Plovers are not natural to the Hatteras area, but your lawsuit complained about this poor little bird. A few miles north of Hatteras point is Pea Island National Wildlife Refuge. It has thousands of acres of shore dedicated to turtles and plovers. South of Hatteras all the way to South Carolina border are miles and miles of open and uninhabited coastal buffer zones. North of Hatteras are thousands of acres of land set aside for birds. North of that is my local Sandbridge area with thousands of acres for the same thing. Virginia's Eastern Shore has thousands of acres for the same thing. Maryland's Eastern Shore has thousand of acres for the same thing. It has to end, Chris. There are ample lands already available all along the Atlantic coast. We all love turtles. They hatch and return to those thousands of open acres every year. There are ample miles of shoreline for turtles and birds. They return to the same protected shoreline every year. All along the coast measures are in place to protect and help them. You do not have a valid point in your suit. Shame on you for what the Audubon has done. Let us humans enjoy something for ourselves and get a real life. We don't want thousands of acres, just a small piece to enjoy for humans.

Please do not send me another cheap canned reply. I took the time to type actual words with my fingers. I expect the same respect from you, Chris, and your society.

Gregory Lepage
Virginia Beach



I have had the pleasure of fishing at Cape Point and visiting Hatteras Island with my wife for the last five years. Our black Lab loves to go for beach walks with my wife and me. We have close friends whom we meet every spring and fall on the Banks, and we enjoy our surf fishing and cookouts together. Back in Ohio, I'm a state wildlife officer by profession, so I realize the need to protect our natural resources. But, that is not accomplished by closing the public out. The National Park Service needs to form partnerships with its user groups and fight together against environmental groups. We're all interested in the welfare of the beaches and wildlife, but not to the exclusion of the public.

Bob Wolfrum
Pettisville, Ohio



I have been coming to Hatteras at least once a year for the past 20 years. I've met some of the greatest people I've ever known there. This situation with the beach closings disturbs me greatly, along with everyone else I know in Tennessee. Please let me know the best way I can help my home away from home. I'm doing all I know to do now. I love you people on the island, though I may not know your name. We have always respected the beach and always take a trash bag to pick up after those who don't. We have had similar things happen here in Tennessee. Freedom in this country is disappearing daily. Keep the faith and be assured that you are not alone in this assault on your rights. Last I heard this is still America, land of the free, home of the brave. I love the islands. Ask up in Salvo, Waves, or Rodanthe if they know Rockytop You may be surprised!

Jerry Loposser
Seymour, Tenn.



Thanks for this information. It's a great public service. As disturbing as it is, this is much more than just a local problem and threat for the OBX community. The general user public and all citizens and foreign visitors who desire access to the shoreline and its unique environment will also be deprived of a basic access right guaranteed many years ago by the U.S. Congress. The general public has no knowledge of this potential beach usage loss, let alone the actual scientific and economic facts surrounding it. Many thanks to your community leaders and elected officials who are working hard to keep the beach open for all of us.
 

Mike Berry
Chapel Hill, N.C.


 

Well, what do you know? We got sucker punched by those who we thought were in it to find solutions. All you have to do is look at the list of Washington lawyers supporting the Defenders and Audubon to see that the only reason they entered into the negotiated rulemaking was to get an inside track to help derail the process and close the beaches forever. It's saddening that these groups would rather sneak in, deceive, and then intimidate with lawsuits to obtain their goals of totally destroying one type of recreation instead of working to satisfy all concerns. I was at the Richmond meeting in January, and even though I wasn't happy with some of the news, I figured a little give and take was inevitable. I guess the gloves are off now, and we all need to get involved if we want to continue to fish the Outer Banks. By the way, I was getting ready to reserve our house for our October trip when I saw this post and read some of the articles. Needless to say, I held off on making my reservation and am now worried about our planned trip in April. I know the $2-$3,000 we spend each week (three weeks each year) isn't much, but the lawsuit says we only contribute .5-.8 percent, so no one will probably miss us anyway. Sorry Frank and Fran, Hatteras Realty, Food Lion, Red Drum, Fishing Hole, Pickled Steamer, Tradewinds Tackle, Howard’s, etc.

Paul Miller
Richmond, Va.


 

The community meeting held Thursday night, March 27, at the Fesseden Center in Buxton was a sobering and realistic presentation of events that have unfolded (and most likely will unfold).Our community is facing the very real predicament of losing access to some of the most vital and enjoyed areas of beach that we have -- not only ORV access -- but TOTAL access to all people. The consequences of this will be catastrophic to our community. Our only viable recourse is to plead our case with our elected representatives (Senators and U.S. Representatives) and ask that they intervene with legislation. All those who believe in freedom and the democratic process and who do not want their rights to access of our beaches taken away, please write to our members of congress immediately!

T. Bentley Crabtree, Jr.
Avon


 
My family and I have been vacationing on Hatteras Island for the past 10 years. The reason we come back is because of the peace, quiet, and solitude. We drove on the beach once at the Point. We respect the dunes and wildlife, but in the past years, more and more visitors aren't. I love the freedom, but the wildlife comes first. Not only do you need to limit the number of vehicles on the beach, but you need to stop building so much. Before you know it, Hatteras will become another Mrtyle Beach. There won't be any islanders left. All the land will be owned commercially, and it won't matter who can or can't drive on the beach anymore. Protect what you have before it's gone!

Patty Thibodeau
Bristol, Conn.



To the good people of Hatteras and Ocracoke and to whom it may concern:
 
My wife and I have just returned from spending 10 days on your beautiful ribbon of sand. I have spent my life fishing pretty well everywhere in North America and have always wanted to fish the “fishiest” place on the continent – that being Hatteras. Last winter we watched all of the Web sites, and every Canadian winter night we dreamed of traveling the beaches in our truck in search of the best surf fishing the East Coast has to offer. We found it from Avon to Ocracoke.
 
Everywhere we stopped people were worried about closures of the beaches and loss of income and business. We are just a newly retired couple from Southern Ontario, Canada, living the dream. We spent close to $3,000 in 10 days from Avon to Ocracoke. We stayed in Buxton but traveled north and south everyday to different ramps to drive and fish on the beaches. During our 10 days we tried to eat in a different restaurant every night. The food was superb, as was the staff in every place we visited. We also stopped in every tackle shop that was open and had no trouble spending money for the new type of tackle and bait we needed. The proprietors kept no secrets from us telling us how, why, where to fish; this is unusual from other fisherman, our experience is that they are usually closed mouthed and secretive. This was not the case, the shop owners were great.
 
Even though the fishing wasn’t fast and furious because of the cold north winds, we were amazed at the camaraderie of the other fisherman on the beach. It was like one big happy family everywhere we stopped along the shores. We saw people stop their four-wheel-drive vehicle in front of us to pick up a lone, windblown piece of litter – the only trash in sight. Amazing in this day and age. We saw no beer bottles, plastic bags, or any other garbage on the beach. Park officials drove by frequently and stopped to talk a few times. It was really a nice place to be. We saw no signs of rowdiness, no alcohol, and no careless driving -- just people having fun with their loved ones.

We talked to our kids every night describing the wonders of this wonderful place, like Cape Point (where the currents collide), an astounding sight to see and not widely known outside of the area. It would be a shame if people were not allowed to get to that place to see it. It would be too far for most people to walk, as with most of the wonders of the beaches. The beaches are an amazing resource that has to be shared. We hope and pray that we will be able to bring our children and grandchildren down here someday too, but if driving on the beach closes, it will be impossible.
 
We are hoping and praying to return this summer and fall and for many years to come.
 

John & Karen Vandivier
Guelph, Ontario
 

 

We've been following this issue carefully for several years now via NCBBA. We own a home in Salvo and visit three to four times per year. We attended the community meeting and have been delivering the message to our neighbors in Salvo, some full-time residents, some part-time like us. To a person, they all thought this was a "driving on the beach" issue. They were all stunned to learn that the judge's decision could end all beach access in certain areas. I'm not sure how to get the word out, but it truly concerns me that most folks identify this as a "fishing and driving on the beach issue."

Even though I'm not a North Carolina resident, I do pay property taxes, so I'm writing the N.C. congressional delegation, as well as my own West Virginia delegation. We are also enlisting support from our fisher friends in West Virginia to stop this gross government involvement in enjoyment of public property.

Polly Moffatt
Charleston, W.Va.

 

I have three properties in Avon. This would be devastating to me personally. Who is valued more - - birds or humans? It seems like government in its finest hour may vote that the interest of birds are greater than me, a taxpayer. I hope and pray the judge makes the right decision for the sake of all of us and keep the beaches open.

Steve Budosh
Towson, Md.



On September 18, 2003, Hatteras Island took the direct hit from Hurricane Isabel, a Category 5 Hurricane for many days before it came ashore. The devastation to the island and residents was heartbreaking. There are many archives available online (Wikipedia-Hurricane Isabel is one.) to those who are not familiar to what happened to Hatteras Island during that storm. I question the blame on ORV use for demolishing the nesting bird population. For prior to Hurricane Isabel, I spent a lot of time novice birdwatching and enjoyed seeing the different birds during different times of the year, migration, nesting, sometimes spotting chicks -- from a great distance with binoculars, never encroaching on the closed areas and respecting the enclosures with the hope that there would be more to see on my next venture.

After Hurricane Isabel, all what was left of Hatteras Island beaches was very different from the day prior to the hurricane. The beach terrain was completely changed. Could it be that the birds have moved onto different areas because of the real nature of the island and its weather patterns and climate changes. It has been documented that wildlife will change/move to avoid Mother Nature’s wrath. I wonder if the Audubon Society ever studied the before and after of the hurricanes. I have not studied this, but through the years, during my times on Hatteras Island, I have noticed that the weather conditions changed what I saw in birdwatching.

My family and I are extremely upset over this entire conflict and hope that it will not come to closing off the beach access to the residents and visitors. It is so one-sided.  Go to the Audubon Society NC Web page and read the article they published, "Beach Bums." There are disturbing pictures and comments. Anyone reading this should try to open his mind and look at the big picture on Hatteras Island. At no point does the Audubon Society show or speak about the effects, disruption, or devastation that Hurricane Isabel had on the bird population and nesting habits.
Hatteras Island residents, non-residents, volunteers, and volunteer organizations all came together after Isabel and brought Hatteras Island back together for the sake of preserving a most beautiful home to people and wildlife alike. We consider our access to driving on the beach a privilege and will do what we can to help preserve the right to do so. We too urge the Park Service and the authorities to re-think this ban and return with a reasonable plan for all. I hate to think what is going to happen to the future of Hatteras Island if this ban becomes fact.


Jan McCrystal
Point Pleasant, N.J., and Frisco


 
My wife and I spend seven months a year enjoying the beaches on Hatteras Island each season. As we are in our 60s, we are not able to carry everything needed to the beach each day. If the beaches are closed to beach driving, we will be forced to leave the area and spend our summers elsewhere.

Bob Jacobs
Rodanthe
 


We respect our beaches, birds, turtles and all animals that share our beaches with us. The beaches have been used by locals and tourist for years. We respect all areas that are closed off for the wildlife. People come here for safe swimming and family fun that they would otherwise not have access to. The people and businesses on the island rely on the tourist for their income. You would be adding people to the streets, homeless, because of the loss of their home here. Please help us. Give us access to our beaches.

Jo Stokes
Buxton


 
Thank you for your continuing excellent coverage of the beach access issue.

BoyerVideo, Inc. captured the emotional involvement of Bobby Otten and John Couch and both men spoke well. Watching and writing here in Baltimore, we also feel very deeply about the possible outcomes of the April 4 hearing. Our investment in Hatteras and Ocracoke is emotional and not monetary, except in terms of supporting the property owners, motel owners and employees, merchants, and commercial fisherman who live there. We will continue our efforts to make people aware of what is happening and contacting our elected officials to try to enlist their support in the fight to save the Outer Banks.

Jim and Paula Brown
Baltimore, Md.
 


We are proud of Rob Alderman’s efforts to keep our beach open.  It is wonderful to see so many people rallying to the cause as a result of his efforts.  On our Web-site www.OuterBanksShells.com, we are asking people to pray for Hatteras Island.  To us, this is the final episode in a long battle to keep our beaches open.  We have given a lot of thought to the problem and have concluded the only thing that will save us now is divine intervention.  We have asked ourselves over and over how anyone could be a member of the Defenders of Wildlife and the National Audubon Society knowing that they will be responsible for not only devastating the economy of this island but also harming little children as a result of their mothers and fathers losing their jobs.  If the members off these organizations really cared about other people, they would be demanding they drop the motion to stop beach driving.  If they refuse to drop the motion, then they should show their concern for others by dropping their membership.  I would hate to lay my head down at night knowing I contribute to hurting little children as well as destroying the happy way of life found on Hatteras and Ocracoke islands.       

Dewey and Mary Parr
Buxton


Fishing is the livelihood of Cape Hatteras. It is what some people go to the island to do. They drive their vehicles on the beach and then turn off their engines. They do not leave the engines running to allow more pollution into the air. Don't you think the building of all these large homes is having a bigger effect on the island than people just driving on the beach? People have been driving on the beach for years, and it is one the things that keeps people coming back each year. The government should stop telling everyone what to do and what to eat and instead fix some very important matters -- like stopping the dumping of toxic waste into the ocean, which has a much larger effect than some vehicles sitting on the beach and people enjoying themselves.

Kathy Grimm
Lansdowne, Pa.
 


I have been four-wheeling and fishing at the Point and Oregon Inlet since the ‘60s. Never in my life have I ever met such nice surf fishermen and residents as in this area. This is my home away from home. To actually see it be taken over by some over zealous organizations would be a catastrophe.

Joe Riplinger
Norfolk, Va.
 



Does anybody actually have a copy of the 1978 plan? If so, rubber stamp it and present it to Judge Boyle.

Tim Sacksteder
Greatfalls, Va.
 


Closing the beaches would be a very ignorant decision for our government. We the people make Hatteras Island survive, and if the beaches are closed, people will have to leave the island. The tourists come to Hatteras for the beaches not the birds. And with the beaches closed, no money will be coming in. Money is already an issue. The people making this decision don't have to depend on money as much as the citizens of the island do. Businesses will have to shut down, and then people will have to move. Closing the beaches is a horrible idea.

Brianna Price
Frisco



The picture (of the celebration of access rally at the Point) is absolutely amazing, and I thank you for getting it together. My immediate family and my in-laws have been going to the beaches for the last 60 years, and I can not imagine not having beach access. If you chose to mount a petition campaign, count me in, along with the 150 men I work with. Perhaps we have the wrong people in positions of power? A couple of self-centered people so wrapped up in their own self importance are a pathetic example of how pleasures are taken from us. Anyone remember prayer in the classroom? If you don't, it is because you are young enough to have idiots like this "look after" your rights. If you do remember prayer in the classroom, how did we let it get away from us? Here is another event that, hopefully, one day we can say, you know, there was a bunch of tree huggers –or sand pounders -- or whatever who tried to keep us from driving on the beach. Let's not let that happen.

Eddie Glover
Vinton, Va.



This is in response to a letter to the editor by P.A.Glass of Rodanthe (in the March 26 letters):
 
I am sorry that narrow mindedness has led you to believe that we are all fat, out-of-shape people and that no other businesses than tackle shops will be affected by great loss of ORV drivers.
 
Maybe you should air your tires down and go out on the beach with your truck for a while, because I don't think you have much of a grip about the economy of Hatteras and Ocracoke islands if you believe the tackle shops will be the only ones suffering.
 
Half the businesses in the Tri-Villages open in late spring and close in early fall. How do you think they will be with the ORVs gone and fishing tournaments gone with them? Restaurants, hotels, rental cottages, art dealers, house cleaners, EVERYONE will suffer their loss.
 
You really need to get out of your house more often.
 

Rob Alderman
Buxton



 
Question for Mr. P. A. Glass in Rodanthe:
 
After this nearly 70-year-old walks out the roughly three miles to the Point with the 2-year-old grandchild toddler, dragging as much stuff with us as we can, could you tell me where I should seek shelter with the toddler when a thunderstorm comes?
 
I've been trying to figure this out but can't seem to come up with a good answer. Might be my age. You seem to have all the answers, so please let me know your thoughts on this.


Ted Hamilton
Salvo



Here is a suggestion of compromise for the nesting vs. driving dilemma on Hatteras beaches.
 
We need to make more suitable areas for nesting bird colonies. How do we do this? Burn and bulldoze all the vegetation from Hatteras Inlet and Cape Point.
 
Before you call me radical, look at the history of this. Up until the late ‘60s, I remember the flats at the inlet. Miles and miles of open mud flats that were surrounded by open, higher sand areas. The birds loved nesting there because it was open, and they could see the predators a long way away.
 
At Cape Point, when you looked from the top of the dunes at ramp 45, all you could see was a desert of sand and then the ocean, no greenery. The birds nested up high on the beach, away from the waterline, so their nests didn’t get overwashed unless it was a bad northeaster. There was no vegetation for predators to hide in, so the birds were much safer. The nests were so far back from the water’s edge that everyone could drive the beach and never worry about getting in the nesting area.
 
The government has unknowingly at the time destroyed most of the good nesting areas by changing the habitat. The pond at the Point was mined for sand that was pumped up the beach. The watershed was changed to drain the area around the park campground so it didn’t flood as much. This drainage water and the enlargement of the pond at the Point have allowed the vegetation to grow out of control. If you go out in the daytime today, you will see cats and raccoons moving around in the shrubs on the beach. That is not natural. Predators need things to hide in so they can sneak up on their prey. Get rid of these hides, and the birds can nest farther up on the beach where it is more natural.
 
In out efforts to stabilize the island, we have messed up the natural balance of animals and sand movement. Stop protecting the dunes and let the island move around, and we will all be better off.
 
Lou Browning
Frisco



My family has been going to the Outer Banks, especially Buxton, Hatteras and Ocracoke, for the last 30 years. Our time spent there is always peaceful yet invigorating as we fish, walk, picnic, and watch the wildlife. It would be a travesty to allow any special interest group to deny the true owners of this public recreational park access.
 
We spend $300-600 every time we go, which is at least 6-8 times a year. We will not go the Outer Banks if we can't drive on the beach. The local economy will be devastated, and generations of tradition will be lost. We are the endangered species.

Connor Dempsey
Wilson, N.C.

 

I really didn't believe it when I first learned of the possibility of closing down the beach at Hatteras. This place is very special to my entire family. My parents are considered locals, because they come down so often -- to enjoy the fishing, the community, the peace and great fun on the beach. Being able to drive out and set up camp during the day, its just an awesome experience. So many great memories, I just can't explain the deep sadness I feel when I even think about it not being open anymore.

Charity Berrios
Manassas, Va.


 
What a sorry sight (at the celebration of beach access rally on March 22). If the persons involved in this theatrical gathering had been paying attention all along, they would likely not have a problem now.

Were they in a coma for 36 years? Did they not see the regulations being put in place on other beaches? Did they not observe the tremendous and damaging increase in beach traffic with the advent of an SUV in every garage?
 
I don't drive my truck on the beach because it shortens its life and because I am not a beach seiner, the “traditional” use allowed for when the beach was made a national park. How does that extend to an accountant in Ohio? From what I've seen, most of the folks out there could stand to get off their fat butts and walk. Just another sign of lazy American entitlement. What an example to set for our kids.

If this privilege is so economically important, why didn't local business owners work to protect it in a proactive manner years ago?
 
I think it telling that someone had to stop each vehicle to remind them to be good citizens before going onto the beach. It shows they are aware of the lack of common sense and respect that are too often reflected in the trashy, rutted remains of a day in one's truck at the beach. Any idiot with four-wheel-drive can go over that access and does – in droves. It is not at all unusual many days in fall to find even more vehicles on the sand than in the aerial picture of the staged demonstration. And not just in that spot, but repeated up and down the island. Are the reactionaries saying that ALL these trucks are necessary for the financial survival of our tackle shops? What about the “traditional” unspoiled beach we used to be known for?

Get a grip, businesses. For years you've chosen to ignore the smoke signals and, indeed, fed them by encouraging irresponsible increases in beach traffic. Despite professed “love” for the beach, not one ever worked to stop abuse of the resource and now are surprised there are consequences. Spend a little energy figuring out how to save your bacon from the embers you let smolder into a blaze.
 
No matter what happens, people will always come to Hatteras and perhaps a few rules will bring a better quality visitor.

P.A. Glass
Rodanthe

 

As a young girl, more than 40 years ago, my family camped at Frisco in the dunes. I was able to learn about and enjoy the beauty that is there for all, the coast of the Outer Banks, Hatteras, and Ocracoke. During the last few years I have been revisiting the places of my youth, driving on the beach, watching the sunsets, and fishing and have decided that I would like to retire to the islands. My decision has been strongly based on the fact that I am able to drive onto the beach and enjoy the solitude, the quiet, the scenery, the fishing, in conjunction with nature. I believe that much has been done to preserve the coast and develop a balance between the people and the wildlife. Preventing access to the beaches will prevent others from enjoying the lifestyle offered. I will pray that the small-minded individuals wishing to destroy a way of life will not be successful.

I recently read a quote regarding a misconception about the strong will survive. While I can't remember the words specifically, I do recall that adaptability is critical to survival. The animals and people of the Outer Banks have learned to adapt and live together with the guidelines already implemented. Good luck to the people of North Carolina's coastal communities. You have done a great job balancing your lifestyle and the wildlife.

Donna Clarke
Chesterfield, Va.


 
Our family has been visiting Hatteras since the early ‘70s. My Mom moved there permanently in the late ‘80s. We visit her at least three times a year. Our days are spent on the beach. We bring food, drinks, cameras, beach gear, the dogs, music, etc. and enjoy every last second of the day there. The memories are priceless. It would devastate us if those beach days came to an end.
 
We just don't get it. No one drives on the dunes area or anywhere near these birds. Please tell me that this is just a sick joke.

Carole Revetti
Leesburg, Va.


 
I lived on Hatteras Island as a child and know lots of people there, and who in the world could take driving on the beach from the islanders? Driving on the beach is a way of life for all who live there and many fish for a living. No driving on the beach is crazy.

Balinda Garris
Greenville, N.C.

 

I am for beach access for all Americans because the beach should not be only for the rich who can afford to sue to prevent the public from accessing the public beaches.

John Geis
Rescue, Va.



I, my family, and friends are long-time visitor to the Outer Banks and the Hatteras Island area. We do enjoy ourselves when we are here. We love it that much we also have a home in Avon.
 
It would be a shame for one person or group to make a decision that could be devastating to the majority of the people who depend on this area for their livelihood. Why can't we all work together to achieve the same goals?   Don’t  take away our right to go on the beach with our vehicles, and that includes fisherman, beachgoers and nature lovers. We all have been for many years driving on these great beaches. I do see people respecting the area and nature in the 18 years that we have been vacationing and visiting this great area.
 
Stan Wuagon
Langhorne, Pa.



One fact I have not seen presented regarding the proposed closing of several specific areas to beach driving in Cape Hatteras National Seashore is that major portions of these areas are ALREADY closed to beach driving. The area I know best is South Point on Ocracoke. More than 90 percent of South Point is ALREADY closed to driving and walking. Only a limited portion along the water's edge is open on part of South Point -- the rest is closed.  And when the Park Service determines that this remaining 5 to 10 percent needs to be temporarily closed, as it did for a month last summer for a pair of nesting piping plovers, than NPS closes it.
 
I have not been to Cape Point lately, but from the Bonner Bridge it certainly looks like a vast portion of the beach there is already closed to driving as a “bird enclosure.” Nor have I been to the other sensitive areas lately, but I suspect large portions of them are already closed to vehicle and human access.
 
So if 80 to 95 percent of these areas is already closed  to walking/driving, what is the science that says closing the last 5 to 15 percent will make a difference to the various bird populations?
 
Perhaps there is a reason for not making this fact more known, but it strikes me as an important point that these prime nesting areas are already being properly protected with beach driving severely restricted to such a small percentage of the areas.
 
Scott Bradley
Ocracoke



I have lived many years in Hatteras and will always consider it to be my home base. The people there are hard workers who care about their land and each other. They live a simple life and rely on tourism to keep their economy going. These people are my family and friends, and I would hate to see their livelihood be destroyed because of closed beaches.

Amy Fike
Jackson, Wyo.


 
I don’t understand why people have to fight for use of a recreational area set aside for recreation by people. Why is this necessary? What will they take away from the people next? Do you think that when this land was originally set aside for recreation, they had said with no access by people, it would have passed? This is just nuts -- animals over people again.

Bonnie Marcey
Falls Church, Va.

 
 
Keep the economy strong. Let the fishing continue. Fishermen are commonly known to respect the land they fish on to the highest standards. One or two bad apples are always present, no matter what you are talking about. Even some birdwatchers sometimes go beyond the boundaries to get a closer look. But most of the fishermen I've seen on the beach are always looking out for the environment and they pick up after others as necessary.

Greg Wiz
Charlotte, N.C.



Closing the beaches will stop not only the most loved recreation for a lot of people who visit but will kill the economy of the island and put the livelihood of all the local people and businesses on the islands at risk. How are they expected to survive? Do a survey of how much money and homes rented against the money spent by the fisherman who visit and live there and see who spends the most. We visit at least four weeks a year and spend $1,500 to $2,000 each week on rentals, food, bait, restaurants, stores, and gas. Do the math. Do the bird watchers spend this much?

Shirley Nickens
Sterling, Va.




Please do what you can to keep the seashore open to fishing. The fishermen and the birds have been co-existing there for a long time. I don't see what all the fuss is about.

Mark Giemza
Niskayuna, N.Y.



 
I agree with public access. Wildlife can adjust to our use of the beach. Adaptability is their strength. Special interests are ruining this great country where freedom is our greatest strength.

Mark Clapp
Wilmington, N.C.



 
Our family lived on Hatteras 13 years and our parents (now with us) lived in Frisco for 21 years. If not for health reasons, we still would be there. Please send our message along to the judge:

The work of the Park Service is to serve, and they should balance that with preserve. First, they should serve the people who pay them and give the people access. Then they should preserve animal life with moderate rules for mankind to be nice to the animals. But to restrict people the right to their own parklands and the use they've had since the beginning of time, means they're off balance and either need to be abolished and help our nations budget or remember their place, which was originally just to pick up trash and clean the public bathrooms, for which I'll remind you, they are very well paid. If they can't do both and do them well, then they're not worth what we pay them.

Gary and Janet Loeffler
Unionville, Va.



 
I and my wife have been going to the village of Buxton and renting the same house for 20 years or more. The beaches are what keep us coming back. Take them away, and we will stop coming, and many more will also, for with out the beaches, what is there to do?
Please don't stop beach access.

Stephen Botelho
Fall River, Mass.

 
 
This whole mess with beach access recently caught my attention, and it absolutely sickens me to think what this would do to your local economy. I have many precious memories of fishing at the Point with my family, and I had always hoped to take my boys there to do the same when they were old enough. I hope to everything holy that the government listens to the people and straightens this mess out. That said, my most treasured memories are of time spent in Avon, Buxton, and on Ocracoke, and regardless of beach access, I will continue to vacation there and patronize the businesses that are owned by local people whom I consider to be friends and family. Good luck to all who are fighting this, and regardless of the outcome, I will be down in June for some much needed vacation time in a place that I love.

Jess Lee
Oil City, Pa.



 
Please save the beach. We enjoy coming down and driving out to the Point to fish and relax. If they take that away, the tourism will decrease, and there will be no Hatteras. Who cares about the birds? Let them nest somewhere else. The government needs to mind its own business and seek another problem.

Bryan Foote
Salem, Va.



 
The people of Hatteras Island are a wonderful and rare breed, and this event (celebration of access rally) just proves it. I have been a coming to Hatteras for almost 20 years, and because of my love for it, my sister relocated to Buxton from New Orleans a few years ago. We now have lots of friends that are islanders, and if anyone is environmentally conscious and takes care of the animals and beach, it is the people who live there and the part-time residents like me. People who are not familiar with this island do not realize how hard it is for people who live there to make a living or afford to live there, and that they make this sacrifice because they love the area/beaches so very much! The Park Service should be able to come up with regulations that can be enforced for anyone visiting who does not respect the area. Don't just close it. Congratulations to the locals who did this. As I said before, you are a rare breed that I love and respect.

Sherry Barto
Roanoke, Va.



Throw the bums out.

The Southern Environmental Law Center, Defenders of Wildlife, and National Audubon Society have given up their right to sit at the negotiated rulemaking table with the rest of the adults. It is a shame that these players want to resort to threatening and childish behavior right before the formal meeting of the negotiated rulemaking groups as they get down to business and serious work begins. This action was carefully planned to divert attention and anger the pro-ORV stakeholders. This action, by them, should be punished by banning their participation in the negotiated rulemaking from now on.

The National Park Service and Supt. Mike Murray have done an outstanding job pushing through the processes to get everybody to the table as fast as federal rules permit. These groups have, at every chance, tried to derail any progress in resolving the dilemma set out in the Cape Hatteras National Seashore founding documents. There is room in the Park for both recreational use and wildlife; neither side can have it all.

The parties bringing this lawsuit are thumbing their noses at the entire rulemaking process. It appears they have no intention to negotiate. The only way back to the negotiated rulemaking table is a written and published contrite apology which spells out that all legal and any other type of delaying actions are stopped and no lawsuit or any other type of action will be pursued. This should stay in effect until the final rules are completed. Otherwise, how will anyone know what the NPS is trying to accomplish will work. If SELC, DOW, and Audubon don’t drop their legal action, they should be thrown off the RegNeg committee, to allow the NPS to finish what has now been started and then tested for several years, without fear of lawsuit.

James Harris
Southern Shores

 
 
I, for one, am glad to see people organizing and standing up to be counted. In today’s world, too often the will of the few is being imposed on the many! Keep fighting, people. It is time to stand up and say enough! While I think the opponents have good intentions, I believe they have gone astray because of the influence of lawyers. After all, they are truly the only ones that stand to benefit.

Steve Giardi
Elysburg, Pa.


 
What a wonderful sight! I only wish I could have been there to join in. Cape Hatteras National Seashore Recreational Area was established as a public park for all of the public to use. If Defenders of Wildlife, Southern Environmental Law Center, NC Audubon, and other environmentalist groups are allowed to get their way, no one will be able to enjoy the wonderful experience of being on a "true" beach. Places like Myrtle Beach, Atlantic Beach, Nags Head, and many other beaches on the coast of North Carolina have been developed and commercialized to the point that it is impossible to see and enjoy what a beach is really all about. CHNSRA is one of the few remaining places where nature has not been and will not ever be taken over by man. This means that I can continue to come to a beautiful and wonderfully educational place and learn new things about wildlife. I can also bring my nieces and nephews down and teach them all about the wonderful life of the beach and how each creature is so special -- relating these lessons into practical lessons for life and how they should grow up being respectful and caring about others, as well as just teaching them how to have fun. If access is stopped, I'll loose that, and those children as well as all future generations will not be able to learn about this wonderful place.

Protection of species is fine, but protection of species does not require a total removal of access. Please help us keep access to this wonderful world open. Without it, many will suffer financially, as well as spiritually. Businesses will be hit hard as many of the people who vacation at CHNSRA will no longer come because of the loss of access. Since the majority of the income for this area is based on tourism/vacation spending, you will be looking at a major disaster for the livelihoods of all. Anyone who truly respects and enjoys the ability to go to CHNSRA and to drive out on the beach to fish, swim, bird watch, or just relax, should join in and help protect the right to access. This is a public park that we should all have access to.

Cathy Almon
Concord, N.C.


 
 
I know everyone is consumed with the election. However, there is a government taking of two North Carolina islands in the name of 12 birds (piping plovers), a bogus issue for many reasons, about to happen. I know you do not have time for long discourses, so trust me about the plovers. A federal judge, one man, is about to close all ORV access to the beaches on Hatteras and Ocracoke islands because the National Park Service has not developed a driving plan that has been its responsibility to develop for some 35 years. The NPS has now admitted its lack of a proper plan and thrown all of us under the bus. Hundreds of families who for generations owed their livelihoods to access to the beaches will now be displaced because the NPS (Department of Interior) have failed the community they are charged with protecting. The history and culture, going back to Blackbeard the pirate, is unique. Please help us.

Mark Levin
New York, N.Y.




The senseless killing of the fox at Cape Point has sickened me.

Martha McCullough
Buxton



 
The smart old fox was out there a few days before (it was shot) also. It was out there eating a young dead pelican and several gulls that didn't make it. Several days with a southerly wind no doubt blew the scent of an easy meal into the dunes. Too bad the Audubon and Defenders of Wildlife folks can't help keep the beaches clean like we try to do. They told me they never had an organized beach cleanup at Cape Hatteras. After all their crying about everything else, I didn't believe that either.

Kevin McCabe
Buxton


 
Fine, protect humans, but do you have to expose children to a shooting. Could the NPS have used a tranquilizer gun? Then if they don't have a way to house the fox or move the fox elsewhere, euthanize it outside of the sight of children.
 
Just seems there could have been a much kinder way of handling this with so many children present.

Virginia Luizer
Buxton



First of all, most of us are just learning about this incident (of the killing of a fox on the beach), and, frankly, we are very disturbed. At what point does it make it okay to use a shotgun, amidst men, women and children, to shoot a wild animal? What ever happened to tranquilizing, caging, testing, and re-releasing the animals in the wild? Was this harmless creature really a danger to anyone? I can see if this animal were running around, foaming at the mouth, and scaring beachgoers, but all it was doing was sitting there, apparently disoriented, and I'm quite sure, scared.
 
So does this mean that if my dog got off of his collar and ran down the beach (and please note, my dog slobbers) with drool all over his face, they would just whip out a shotgun and pull the trigger without question?
 
In my mind, the NPS is there to protect wildlife, beaches, the surrounding area, and the animals in it. It's obvious that they're not. What if this ranger missed? What if he/she hit a car, or even a person? How exactly would that be handled? Would they just cover it up like they have this?
 
So the moral of this story is -- don't go to the beach donning a fuzzy jacket and get confused about your surroundings- you might get shot, and I can guarantee that all those people that promised to protect you won't.

Missy Quidley
Buxton



 
Lynne Murray has done a magnificent job in supplying current event photos to The Island Free Press. Thanks for a job well done, Lynne!

Andy Toth
Pittsburgh, Pa.



More on beach access

More letters on the beach access issues also came from folks who oppose an injunction on ORVs, fondly remember 30 or 40 years of driving on the beach and going to the Point, support the efforts to stop the lawsuit and injunctions, wish they could have been at the celebration of access rally or the community meeting, and want to help.  They are:

William Fortune, Boonesville, Va.
Ali Kerekes, Kill Devil Hills
Kerri Brunton Valentine, Ashland, Va.
Rich Smith, Seaville, N.J.
Craig Milfford, Cary, N.C.
Tom Zirkle, Winchester, Va.
Tina Twigg, Leonardtown, Md.
Edward Shapiro, Philadelphia, Pa.
Bob Lick, Cheyenne, Wyo.
Jo and Garry Moorefield, Roanoke, Va.
Scott Tyson, Charlotte, N.C.
Richard Clinton, Centreville, Va.
Sandy McCall, Elizabeth, Pa.
William Cuthrell, Beaufort, N.C.
Jeff Bryant, Greensboro, N.C



Celebration of Access Rally

The Island Free Press received more brief comments on the article on the Celebration of Beach Access rally on Saturday, March 22.  The writers supported the organizer of the rally, Rob Alderman, and thought he did a great job.  They also expressed their solidarity with all who attended and wished they could have been there. And, finally they supported continued beach access

These letter writers are:

Bob Eckler, Mechanicsville, Va., NCBBA 12122
Eddie Fort, Hardy, Va.
C. Wayne Lammers, Memphis, Tenn.
Meghan Wollyung, Reading, Pa.
Pfatrick Crute, Chesapeake, Va.
Darlene Zubal, Freeport, Pa.
Tom Cahall, Georgetown, Del.
P. Tyson, Athens, Ga.
Carol Tyndall, Williamsburg, Va.
Chip Illian, Millsboro, Del.
Hank Pryce, Kill Devil Hills
Robert Kinzer, Utica, Mich.
Jim Keene, North Carolina Beach Buggy Association
Betty Russell, Martinsburg, W.Va.
Phyllis S. Harrell, Belvidere, N.C.
John Fedorowicz, Rydal, Pa.
Ernie Smith, Wilson, N.C.
Chuck Vernon, Falls Church, Va.
Gloria Van Nostrand, Louisville, Ky.
June McCoy, Yorktown, Va.
Jim Walls, Royersford, Pa.
Jerry Posenau, Mechanicsville, Va.
Michael Sicilia, Barnegut, N.J.
Steven Spence, Blackstone, Va.
Garry Dean Smith, Winston-Salem, Va.
Clayton Diggs, Lanexa, Va.
Hawk Hawkins, Mechanicsville, Va.
Tom Todd, Salisbury, Md.
Harold E. Taylor, Manassas, Va.
Delores and Neil Swartz, Avon
Capt. Oak, Indian River, Del.
Mark Carter, Charlotte, N.C.
Tony Ingram, Sandston, Va.
Niki Brooks, Henrico, Va.


Readers weigh in on ORV Access Issues


 
I will be 80 years old this year and was at the meeting when the Park Service promised that no one would ever be allowed to stop beach driving. Does the promise by officials of our government mean nothing? Someone with enough power has to stop these idiots that are trying to ruin our economy.

Carol Dillon
Buxton

 
I usually go to Nags Head/Hatteras several times a year and rent a house from Village Realty at least once every year. If they kick us off of the beaches and don't want our money, then I will go somewhere else where I feel welcomed! I may cancel my reservation this year.

Larry Claytor
Greenwood, Va.

 
I applaud everyone who stood up and made a statement at the negotiated rulemaking meeting. I am only sad that I couldn't be there to tell them how I and my family feel about the closure of the beaches to ORVs. I truly get furious just thinking about it. My heart is with everyone living on Hatteras Island and Ocracoke. Three cheers for those who spoke their minds.

Betty Russell
Martinsburg, W.Va.

 
I pray that the outcome of the ORV dilemma is solved for the good of the community. Hatteras is a beautiful place, and we are so lucky to have such a treasure to visit. I hope your community thrives and drives. Drumwagon Web site has a fish report site, and a regular on the site "Gasdrum" posted "took it for granted." Believe me that says it all! Although he is talking about Cape Lookout, it all applies to the Outer Banks and to all nature and recreation areas.

Kathy Freeborn
West Grove, Pa.

 
If the beach is closed to vehicular traffic, it would end one of the main reasons we visit Hatteras several times a year. My wife’s health conditions prevent her from walking over to the beach. I just replaced an SUV in December to use on our visits. Beach access is one of the special things about Hatteras. I guess we could look at Corolla, unless it is closed too.
 
Bruce Holmes
Vienna, W.Va.

 
I'm thinking about people who come over to the U.S. and think that this is freedom. Where is it, I ask? God gave everyone this island and land for us to be free to do what we would like to do -- and fishing and making this economy grow was what we decided to do with it. The government and environmentalists are making the decisions. We live in peace with the other animals around us. Why not the birds, turtles, and other sea animals? This raises another question: If they are so worried about the birds, then why didn’t they come to the aid of some that they were notified were hurt? It seems like the government and environmentalists are not happy and are bored in doing any thing, except going to court and being on TV and radio. They just are tired of sitting and doing nothing. So they come up with the thing so they can disrupt our lives.

Tamara Pittman
Avon

 
Yes, I do have something to say about this. What are these environmentalist people thinking that they are trying to do? The Park Service already ropes off and takes care of the birds and turtles. The environmentalist people are crazy.  I go to Hatteras Island every other weekend to fish and stay there a week on vacation in Avon. What are hey trying to do? Put everybody on the island out of business? That’s what will happen if the beach driving is stopped. They don’t see the family fun and enjoyment that goes on in the beach driving community.  I hope they will see the light. No beach driving will kill the island and a lot of family vacations.

Brad Winslow
Elizabeth City, N.C.

 
I am writing to you as a concerned citizen fearing that the rights of millions of recreational users (as authorized by Congress back in 1937) will be naively taken away because of misinformation by a well-organized few. Furthermore and more importantly, the economic livelihood of the good people in Dare and Hyde counties will be devastated should the upcoming April 4 federal court ruling come in favor of banning off-road vehicles in the park.
 
As stated in the Dare/Hyde county response, it should be known that in 1937, Congress passed a law, creating the Cape Hatteras National Seashore and stating that “...said area shall be, and is, established, dedicated, and set apart as a national seashore recreational area for the benefit and enjoyment of the people and shall be known as the Cape Hatteras National Seashore Recreational Area.”

Cape Hatteras was our nation’s first national seashore park and happens to be the “Eighth Wonder” of the world. Closing this off to the public would be a national travesty.
I want to thank you for this article and letting the public know that this is real, and the time is “NOW” to help the residents of Hatteras Island.

I’ve been an avid surf fisherman for more than 28 years, and as you are well aware, I can testify that all the residents of Hatteras Island and avid surf fisherman around the nation are the true environmentalists, keepers of the seashore, and work closely with the National Park Service to enforce the current regulations of “OUR” national park. The allegations in the federal lawsuit being brought against the National Park Service are subjective at best, not backed by approved economic and environmental impact studies, opinions in nature, once again, not backed by hard scientific data.

If one were to compare the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s yearly public posted Atlantic Coast Piping Plover population estimates for North Carolina coasts against North Carolina State University's yearly data for number of hurricane/tropical storm direct hits to the North Carolina coast (not including nor’easters), you would find that the Plovers increase/decline numbers are directly related, specifically for years 1998, 1999, 2002, 2003, and 2004. Spock would argue it is logical that the most probable cause of decline to the plover population is Mother Nature, followed by natural predators, not off road vehicles. In fact, USFWS data show that plover numbers have increased for 2005, 2006, and 2007, in which we have had mild hurricane/tropical storm seasons.
 
I can only pray that on April 4, the federal judge will rule, based upon current written law, and be influenced by scientific data and approved economic/environmental impact studies, not by opinions and subjective statements. God save our seashore and Hatteras Island.
 
Scott “Scooter” Lambright
Virginia Beach

 
Thank you, Ms. Nolan for this balanced, thorough reporting. I have been surf fishing Hatteras Island several times yearly for 25 years. This topic and the wonderful people of Hatteras are near to my heart. As a disabled fisherman, ORV access is crucial for me to continue with my passion. Keep up the good work!

Steven Spence
Blackstone, Va.

 
I would just like to thank you for your hard work involving our access to the beaches. I spent my honeymoon on Hatteras Island in 1976 and have been going down ever since. If ORV use is banned, I will not go as much as I do now. My bud and I fish at least three times a year on the beaches Hatteras and Ocracoke.

Mike McKeen
Crosswicks, N.J.
 
 
I'm from Pennsylvania and have spent several summer vacations on OBX with my family. We all love being there, not just for fishing or for driving on the beach, but we enjoy the degree of solitude we get when we are on Hatteras Island.
 
Keep up the good work on behalf of those of us who do not want this privilege taken away. Generations who follow us should be able to partake in the enjoyment of the seashore and all the opportunities it offers.
 
Hats off to you and thanks again for your efforts.

Steve Harter
Hollywood, Pa.

 
I am in support of continuing to be able to drive on the beach. I do not believe enough has been done to work out a plan where recreational fishermen and wildlife folks can work together. I believe it is a power struggle to see who has control, rather than trying to reach a compromise.

Horace Bell
Currituck, N.C.



Free beach access is vitally important to all beach lovers, whether they just stroll on them in the midnight breeze or if they are trying to catch the big one that just barely got away.
 
As for surfers, they are always willing to share their special stories of how hollow it was or as fishermen do, how big it was, but the special stories are always those shared with friends when they catch it just right, uncrowded, with their friends.
 
As a surfer since 1962, I discovered Cape Hatteras long before it was popular. I was lucky. My dad was a hardcore, good – no, a great – fisherman who loved Cape Hatteras and the uncrowded areas that others seemed to know nothing about.
 
Throughout the ‘60s was the best of times because it felt like our very own paradise.
 
Yes, time does change many things, and we know that it is often times called progress.
 
Once again, as fishermen, surfers, and just ordinary beach lovers, we know that if any beach in the world closes off access, then we have all lost.
 
Crowding people into “commercial zones” is never a viable alternative.
In the case of the Outer Banks and, especially Cape Hatteras, we all know that it isn't the buildings, it isn't the glitter, nor is it hype that attracts the masses. It is an attraction that few areas are blessed with at all. God did this area well. Most men don't realize how really perfect it is.
 
It is simply the ocean, the beaches, the friendliness of locals, and the sense of peace that the area naturally offers.
 
I have no answers, nor do I have a viable solution, but I know for sure that, yes, the environment is important, but certainly not the most important. Beach access, free beach access is the attraction and the freedom is worth protecting.
 
If this right is denied to those who love this area the most, then what we have really lost is our rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
 
Aren't we as Americans guaranteed those rights?
 
Shame on those who are blinded by either greed or by some misguided environmental political power move that blinds their perspective.
 
Human rights should be held in the highest regard and those who have never set foot on the sands of Cape Hatteras to fish, surf, or even walk, will never understand nature’s freedom and how it enriches one's soul.
 
Collectively we all are caretakers of the coast and have been long before this controversial issue.
 
I pray that the decision-makers rule in favor of exactly what the locals desire and that blind ignorance doesn't prevail.
 
Just look north to Virginia or south to Myrtle Beach and then breathe in the salt air slowly in Hatteras.
 
What you're breathing in is freedom, and that is definitely worth protecting and educating others of its value.
 
Those opposing freedom should leave well enough alone and go home.
 
I predict maybe a long battle, and at times it may even feel like a losing battle, but the Hatteras I have grown to know always seems to win.
 
Why, you may ask, and I'll say simply just this -- because it's Hatteras.
 
If your community wins, we all win.
 
Rob Beedie
Global Surfing Network
http://www.GlobalSurfNetwork.com


 
It appears that some groups have lost sight of the mission of the National Park Service. Basically, the NPS is charged with task of preserving the environment for current and future generations to see and enjoy. Below is a paragraph taken from the National Park Service's Web site:
 
"As a government agency, the NPS has reflected and participated in national discussions about the environment and its relationship to society. Parks provide specific evidence about the history of conservation and management of natural resources and about the economic, ecological, and aesthetic dimensions of the public lands. Parks illuminate changes in the very concept of nature and wilderness, the economic interests involved in the setting aside and development of public lands, and ways Americans experience nature and wilderness in shifting patterns of tourism and recreation."

Dennis Schmidt
Berlin, N.J.


I must commend you for your close attention to the threat to access at the Cape Hatteras National Seashore as most recently demonstrated in the March 16 article (Attorneys for Dare, Hyde, and CHAPA Weigh in on Injunction Request). Although I am separated by hundreds of miles from the CHNS area, I find your publication a tremendous resource for up-to-the-minute information that keeps me abreast on this matter. I particularly appreciate the links you provide to the court documents.
 
My time in the area is spent fishing from the beach. I need the residents and the businesses in the area, from Avon to Ocracoke, that help make my multiple yearly visits enjoyable. This injunction request, if granted, not only restricts beach access to residents and visitors alike, but also severely affects those who provide the goods and services I and my family need. It is these people who would personally experience the negative economic impact an injunction would bring.
 
Again, thank you for your efforts that keeps all of us, residents and visitors, alike, informed.
 
George Mood
Millsboro, Del.


 
Thank you for your very timely article and the great link to the response by our side.
We are trying to keep up with the rapidly changing situation from here in Baltimore, and without the work you and other people who love the Outer Banks have performed to keep the Internet postings current, it would not be possible.

We and our sons have been responsible ORV operators and bird-loving surfers for 20 years, and the thought of key areas of the beach being off limits is very disheartening.
Thanks again, and we will keep writing and e-mailing in our efforts to keep the beaches open.

Jim and Paula Brown
Baltimore, Md.


 
Thank you for the March 16 article. After reading the transcript from the scheduling hearing, I thought that the judge had all but decided to issue the injunction. The Dare/Hyde/CHAPA response is the best news to date. I've been a "Hatteras Heaver" for 30 years. I've raised my (now 26- and 21-year-old) children on Cape Point sun, sand, and surf fishing. Their experiences have taught them how to enjoy and respect nature. We now have a trailer in Cape Woods Resort and, like many Virginians, spend about 80 percent of our recreational budget on Hatteras and Ocracoke islands. It continues to be a family affair for us, as my brother, brother-in-law, and closest friends have joined us at Cape Woods. We meet at the beach almost every weekend between March and December, and we would be devastated without ORV beach access.

Alan Bartlett
Chesapeake, Va.
 


To listen to the environmental folks you would think that there are millions of birds that will be affected by thousands of Jeeps, when, in fact, there are only a few birds and fewer Jeeps on a given day. This shows that a "few" can affect the rights of "many." We need to fight to keep this pushy group to keep the Outer Banks open to all people who have had access for fishing and recreation with their RVs for many years. It will not only affect the fishermen, but the homeowners who rent their homes to these folks, the businesses who cater to the fishermen, and the vacationers who will be denied access to the beach that is hard to reach without RVs.

Stop the environmental groups who are trying to inflict their agenda onto many who will be affected by this crazy idea. Next they will want to ban people.

Cassandra Sloop
Chapel Hill, N.C.

 

I have been coming to the beaches of Hatteras Island for 10 years to relax and fish. It would be a travesty if they were closed. Thank you for keeping up the fight. We are doing what we can from out of state.

Chris Suchon
Temple, Pa.

 
I am glad to see that the counties are going to fight this high-handed attempt by the environmentalists to close the beaches. I, for one, had planned a trip to the OBX with a group of friends in April or May. Just the threat of closing the beach had us canceling our plans. None of us can afford to waste our vacation time and money to make the drive and not be able to fish. I am, however, very disappointed that the feds are apparently not putting up a fight.

Donald Hoy
Collegeville, Pa.


Thank you, Lord, for finally giving the CHAPA (Cape Hatteras Access Preservation Alliance) boys some ammunition in thinking about filing this on the grounds of the irreparable economic grounds. It's about time someone starts to think about the impact on the full-time residents of the island. Could you even imagine if this lawsuit was won by those environmentalists what the economic effect would be? Thank you to CHAPA and no thank you to the Park Service.

Roger Marsh
Plantation, Fla.


 
I believe closing of the beaches to ORVs will truly hurt the tourism, economy, and the welfare of those who make a living from the beach area. There are hundreds miles of nesting areas that are less accessible than the areas in question.

John Riemann
Lancaster, S.C.



My husband and I started coming to Hatteras Island in the early 1960s. We tent camped for years at Buxton and Frisco. We would also rent houses in the winter. As we grew older, camping became impossible due to health problems. We eventually purchased a home in Frisco, which we use year around. When my husband became disabled, the only way to get him to the beach was by our SUV. He loved to sit and watch the ocean and shorebirds. I have had two strokes and can no longer walk long distances. We do not race around tearing up the beach or nesting sites. If this judge closes the beach to SUVs, he will be taking away the rights of the disabled to get out on the beach. The only endangered species on Hatteras Island are the people who have lived there for years and years and the villages of the Outer Banks whose livelihood comes from the tourist trade. I am not anti-wildlife, but we need to be reasonable.
 
Joan Gray
Waynesville, Ohio



What I said in my last e-mail, I reiterate here.  Hatteras is a place/destination for surf fishing.  The Point is among the greatest destinations for us when we come down.  If this pending regulation is enforced, say goodbye to all but people who rent beachfront houses.  I can’t believe the realty companies are not stepping forward.  This will kill them and their rentals.

Neil Donovan
Newport, Del.



Comments: I feel up lifted reading the letters to the Editor. All of you who have access to The Island Free Press, please send this Web site to everyone you know. More folks need to know what is happening with the closure to the beaches. It is amazing the number of folks who come to Hatteras Island.  Everyone needs to know this devastating information. I would hope that the word would spread across the U.S. and the world. Hatteras is unique and the ability to drive on the beaches and enjoy the sun, beaches, fishing, families, shelling, scenery - it goes on and on - makes my heart feel so good. The thought of that being taken away is so sad. Get the word out to everyone you know. Ask them to write to the N.C. legislature and whomever you know on a national level. Everyone can pull together for such a good cause - keeping the beaches open for all. We need help from everyone.

Betty Russell
Martinsburg, W.Va.



We wish we had known about the gathering on March 8. We sure thought it was necessary that such a display was made. Thank you, Island Free Press, for providing a forum for discourse amongst Hatteras Island residents and friends. We all love nature, and the serenity that life on Hatteras provides for us. No one who lives or visits here wants to see it destroyed. But compromise we must. The unchecked power that the Park Service wields will crush the tiny economy of Hatteras. As hundreds of tourists leave our beaches, feeling harassed by busybody park rangers, they will not fail to report their tales of woe to other potential Hatteras Island visitors -- and drive them to vacation elsewhere! Islanders and small businesses grasping for a foothold in the local economy are cut down and hacked by relentless government meddling and non-stop altering of rules and policies.

Where will it end? Perhaps when they have driven us all out of business and there are no people here to govern.

Nikki Spears
Hatteras



A letter from the editor

We thank Rob Alderman of the Hatteras Island Fishing Militia (www.fishmilitia.com) for posting a message on some Internet boards complimenting The Island Free Press for its fair and accurate coverage of beach access issues and asking folks to e-mail me their thanks and appreciation for the work that we at the newspaper do to inform and explain. 

I heard from many of you, and now it’s my turn to say thank you to:

Jeff Madre of Elizabeth City, N.C.
Seth Torrence of Richmond, Va.
Corrine of Kill Devil Hills
Tom Todd of Salisbury, Md.
Joe McDonough of Norfolk, Va.
Todd Sugg of Kernersville, N.C.
Jeffrey “Wheat” Golding of Buxton
Jeff Madre of Elizabeth City, N.C.
Darryl Ellyson  of Chesterfield, Va.
Jim Harris of Harris, N.C.
Will Norris of Chester, Va.
Scot King of Durham, N.C.
 Robbie Hanks of Keysville, Va.
 James Lea
Jim Walls of Royersford, Pa.
Chuck Deal of McLeansville, N.C.
Bruce Leblanc of Clifton Heights, Pa.
Bob King of Midlothian, Va.
Doug Crumpton of Burlington, N.C.
W.D. Brand

Thank you for reading The Island Free Press and thanks for sending messages.  And we thank Rob Alderman for being a tireless supporter of our newspaper.  He is also working hard to keep the public informed on a very important issue that will affect all of us – residents and visitors.

Irene Nolan
Island Free Press
Frisco



More on ORVs on the seashore beaches

Here's all I have to say to Defenders of Wildlife and the Southern Environmental Law Center:
 
I write to you to express my concerns about your injunction which seeks to severely limit access to the beaches of Cape Hatteras National Seashore Recreation Area (CHNSRA).
 
The beach closures the injunction seeks amount to a land grab that would drive away large numbers of visitors and strangle the island economy. Your attacks divert time, energy, and resources from other vital issues confronting the island communities, such as enforcement of existing park rules and regulations, the long overdue replacement of the Bonner Bridge, and the preservation of historic sites.
 
Should this injunction be granted, it is a slap in the face of all tax-paying Americans who enjoy our national parks responsibly. It states loud and clear that environmental extremists will be rewarded for dishonesty and circumventing democratic processes. It is yet another salvo in the special interest war against the American middle class.
 
I fully support the negotiated rulemaking process and the cooperation and compromise it asks all parties to make. I believe that the current temporary beach closures, flexible in size and scope, are a scientifically balanced, reasonable, and enforceable management tools to protect all shorebirds and seashore wildlife on CHNSRA beaches. Temporary beach closures balance the needs of the resource with the tax-paying public's expectation of free access to the recreational seashore.
 
My tax dollars pay for Cape Hatteras National Seashore Recreation Area, and I'm going to recreate as I see fit, while being a responsible steward and following park rules. Environmental extremist assaults against the rights of the middle class Americans and access to our national parks need to stop now. I've contacted my federal and state representatives to voice my displeasure about your injunction. Piping plovers aren't successful at Hatteras because the nor'easters and ocean overwash destroy their nests, not ORVs. If the piping plover can't evolve and the weather patterns don't change, then all the lawyers, money, rules, and regulations of humankind won't save it.
 
The surf fishing community at Cape Hatteras has done more to promote protection of the barrier islands, conservation of coastal fishing resources, and preservation of the Hatteras and Ocracoke island lifestyle than your lawsuit will ever accomplish. The current NPS resource closures are more than adequate to balance the recreational and resource stewardship duties of the park.

We are all adults. It's time to drop the suit and honor your agreement to take part in a constructive negotiated rule making process.

Derek Scott
West Chester, Pa.



I have been visiting the Outer Banks for 50 years, and one of the main attractions is the accessibility to the beach by driving on the beach and the feeling of being "isolated" while on the beach. If the Defender of Wildlife and the Audubon Society are allowed to impose their ban of beach driving, I know the economy of the region will be severely adversely impacted by the loss of revenue. My family has disabled and elderly members with limited mobility who otherwise would not be able to walk the distance from the parking lot across the dunes to the beach -- not even to mention the fishermen in my family who have all their equipment to transport to the beach. Therefore, we will definitely be one of the families who will reconsider our four weeks per year at the Outer Banks and will look for other places to vacation.

I hope that the Outer Bankers will prevail. I also hope that the protectors of wildlife and the committees tasked with coming up with an ORV management plan can work together to make a fair compromise for all of us.

Gertrude Byrd

Durham, N.C.

 
My family has vacationed in Hatteras every summer for my entire life. (I'm 29 now.) Our daily tradition while on vacation includes driving out on the beach where we spend the day enjoying the beautiful beaches that the island has to offer. We have always respected the laws (as do the majority of people on the beach) and respected the wildlife there.

If the beaches are closed to vehicles, I feel we will no longer visit Hatteras Island. I feel that thousands of tourists will not visit Hatteras, thus practically murdering the economy there that depends almost solely on the summer tourism. I love Hatteras and hope and pray that this law is not passed. If there are issues with wildlife, I'm sure there are other alternatives rather than completely closing the beaches on the island. I encourage our government officials to put their heads together and come up with a solution that suits both humans and wildlife.
 
Our visits are is a family tradition that my family will treasure forever.

Nicole Simon
Richmond, Va.


 
I agree that closing the beaches to vehicles would be catastrophic to the Outer Banks. My family has been enjoying the beaches every summer for the last 30 years. My children were brought up on the "driving on the beach" vacations every year. If they stopped allowing us to drive out onto the beaches, then the beaches would be inaccessible, except for the handful of beachfront homes. What a shame that would be. I would personally be devastated.

Kim Taylor
Mechanicsville, Va.


I can not believe this. I have been going to the Point and farther south all of my life. The economy on the Outer Banks will absolutely tank if this were to happen. One other thing is that in the 17 years (Yes, I am 17.) that I have been going to the beach, my family has never seen birds in those dumb nesting areas. I don't understand why a few dumb people in their lifted beat-up trucks and Jeeps have to tear everything up on the beaches and make everyone suffer from what they do.

What they are talking about doing is terrible. I am a member of the Outer Banks Preservation Association and proudly display the license plate on the front of my truck and any other bumper stickers I get on a rack I use to carry my canoe and kayak.

Jonathan Pullen
Lynchburg, Va.




A celebration of beach access at Cape Point


I have been coming to Cape Hatteras National Seashore for 25 years now. My parents own property on the sound in Brigand's Bay. Even though the water is right out front of their house, we still drive to the beach for the thrill and excitement of being able to drive on the beach. I agree with Steven Stepp of Hampton, Va. If I can't drive on the beach, I might as well stay at the Jersey Shore and save myself some money and time.
You have already put in the law requiring fishing permits, now you want to close beach access. How far behind are beach tags? You know all of this killed the Jersey Shore. Is that what you want to happen to Cape Hatteras?

Heather White
Somerdale, N.J.

 
If beach access is taken away from Hatteras Island, the heartbeat of the island will be taken away. We have to do what is right, find a way to make it work.

Joel Groetsch
Avon

 
I hope this effort is rewarded. They just can't close our beaches.

Anthony Bowers
Avon


Thank all of for what you are doing. I wish I could have joined you. I do what I can as far as letters and e-mails from so far away to save the place on earth I love so.

Kevin Freeland
Hornell, N.Y.


Sorry I missed the celebration on Saturday. I was in Buxton that weekend with my two sisters and some friends. Our family dates back well over 100 years on Hatteras Island. Please keep me informed of any news or possible upcoming events in the future.

Cantwell Thomas Miller, III
Chesapeake, Va.




Sen. Basnight weighs in on ORV use on seashore beaches

(State Sen. Marc Basnight sent the following letter on March 13 voicing his support for continued off-road vehicle access to the Cape Hatteras National Seashore and asking the federal government to vigorously fight any lawsuit restricting this access. The letter is to Mike Murray, superintendent of the Cape Hatteras National Seashore.)

Dear Superintendent Murray:

I appreciate your commitment to our National Seashore and to making our resources available to visitors and residents alike.  I truly believe that the gifts that Nature has given our community must remain open and accessible to the public, so that all can enjoy and appreciate those bounties – and, most importantly, learn from them the great importance of environmental stewardship.

The 2007 federal plan to regulate off-road vehicle use was adopted through a public process and is being implemented in a fair and effective way.  I credit you and your staff for all your hard work in developing this plan, and I am thankful your efforts to protect the seashore while preserving reasonable public access to it.

I am deeply troubled, as I know you are, by the current lawsuit against the National Park Service by the Defenders of Wildlife and the National Audubon Society regarding off-road vehicle access to the Cape Hatteras National Seashore.  The residents, visitors, property owners and business owners on Hatteras and Ocracoke Islands are extremely worried about the outcome of this lawsuit.  A ruling against the United States in this matter could possibly be the ruin of the economy and culture of both islands. 

The off-road vehicle users who visit our seashore are some of the most conscientious conservationists and environmentalists I’ve ever met.  They work day in and day out to protect the beach through volunteering.  They assist the Park Service, help monitor the beach, report violations and assist with litter management.  The off-road vehicle user groups are mainly comprised of good-intentioned, law-abiding members who work diligently to protect their most prized resource, the beach.  This seashore is the heart of our coastal heritage and culture, and to prevent public access to it will only deprive future generations of knowledge and appreciation of this heritage and resource. 

The economies of Hatteras and Ocracoke depend solely upon fishing and tourism.  Visitors from all over America – and from other countries as well – flock to both islands throughout the year for all types of recreation, especially fishing.  The surf fishing off the coasts of Hatteras and Ocracoke islands is world renowned to be the best on the East Coast.  Losing visitor access to this national treasure would be a devastating blow to our local community.

As tourism is such a key engine in North Carolina’s economy, I would argue that the state, too, has a vital interest in preserving access to the seashore.  With that in mind, I have asked the North Carolina Attorney General’s office to explore all possible avenues for the state to support the federal government in this lawsuit.

I hope the federal government will fight this lawsuit with every available resource.  I truly believe, as I know you do, that preserving access to the seashore is absolutely critical to protect our cultural heritage, our economy, and the public’s right of access to their seashore.  Please know that I stand ready and willing to assist you in any way possible to protect this valuable resource for generations to come.

Marc Basnight
President Pro Tempore
North Carolina State Senate
Raleigh




Winter surfing

Thanks again to Daniel Pullen and The Island Free Press for the surfing articles.
All East Coast surfers make a pilgrimage to visit Hatteras, the undisputed capital of East Coast surfing.

For New Jersey surfers like me who return at least twice a year, it is the warmer weather and water that draws us as well.

I agree with the love/hate thing, but this is cold up here. It was 30 degrees this past Sunday morning, and the wind was 30-40 mph with gusts to 50 for a wind chill well below freezing. The water was around 38 degrees.

However, thanks to the excellent wetsuits these days I surfed perfect waves for two hours, and didn't feel it until my feet started feeling cold the last half hour I was out.
It took me 24 hours to get the after-surf chill out of me, but it was worth it.
I surfed the Casino Pier in Seaside Heights with only a couple of guys. It is one of the best spots for waves on the East Coast and is a crowded nightmare when the weather is warm.

Yes, to hate it for the cold is to love it for having it all to ourselves, and love conquers all.

Michael Letso
Chadwick Beach, N.J.




This letter was sent to our elected officials

My husband and I retired to Hatteras Island to live our “golden years” in a place we love. We worked for many years to achieve this dream. We volunteer with the National Park Service, participate with user groups doing beach cleanup and maintenance, and I make quilts for charity or to raffle to provide money for educational scholarships.

Our daughters and now our grandchildren have vacationed with us here on Hatteras Island for years. My young grandson overcame his fear of the water at South Beach. A small pond develops there in the summer and is an ideal place for young children to frolic in saltwater. A short walk away is Cape Point -- the premier surf fishing spot on the East coast and close by also are the shallows where some of the older children can learn to boogie board. It is a spot for youngsters and fishermen, even Grams and Grandpa. It is a place for families to enjoy the beach and make memories.

On April 3, it may be closed to ORV access. The only limited parking is two miles away -- not possible for young people or fishermen carrying gear, umbrellas, coolers, or seniors with arthritic knees to traverse.

We watch the fishermen in the rental cottages on our street in the spring and fall. They leave before dawn to fish Oregon Inlet, Cape Point, or Hatteras Inlet. They don't have the money to rent a charter boat for $850 a day. They shop in the local markets or eat out in restaurants. They come in groups of two to 10 or more. Just “the guys.” On April 3, all these great fishing spots might be closed to ORV access.

What will happen to the economy of Hatteras Island if the pending lawsuit prohibiting access is granted? Who will continue to vacation here? Not all the beach will be closed, but the areas left open will be overused. It will certainly not be the same memories the Swartz Family has made for the past 25 years.

Dare County receives one quarter of its income from Hatteras Island and sends a good portion to the State of North Carolina. Local businesses, rental cottage owners, management companies, and property owners like myself will suffer financial loss.
 
Please help us! Please, contact the Department of the Interior and urge them to defend the National Park Service and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in this pending lawsuit. Also, please make a public statement of your own on this matter.

Dolores and Neil Swartz
Avon

 
A wonderful show of support for responsible recreational access! To brave the weather "fury" that Cape Hatteras deals out from time to time was awesome! Fishermen hanging together, choosing not to hang separately.

John Couch
Buxton
 
I would like to thank everybody involved in the effort to save our ORV access to the Outer Banks.  I’m sorry that we cannot make it to any events -- work, school, and a 12-hour drive is a little much. We come down twice a year and have been for the last five years. Once again, thank you very much.

Craig Rauhecker
Huntington, W.Va.

 
I was born and raised in Hatteras.  My mother and father fished off the beach until they got to sick to do so. They drove their vehicles on the beaches whenever they wanted. I am now 64 years old and have had the freedom to drive on the beach whenever I want.I feel that my children and grandchildren should have the same freedom.

Iva Printz
Frisco

 
I just read the article about several hundred people gathering at Cape Point to celebrate beach access. I applaud everyone who went to the Point today, March 8, 2008, to celebrate in the kind of weather you had on the island throughout the day. Like many others, my husband and I vacationed on Hatteras Island for 25 years with our children and families and love driving to the Point to fish, relax, and collect shells. In 2001, our dream came true when we bought our retirement home in Avon, looking forward to being able to explore the beaches, with our grandchildren, in our ORV as often as we wanted.

I am retired now, and my husband will be retiring soon. We've waited for years to be able to call Hatteras Island our home and enjoy everything it has to offer, including driving on the beach. It's very sad to think that an environmentalist group could have such power and control over what happens on Hatteras Island. First they hinder the replacement of the Bonner Bridge, which presents a very real danger to everyone who drives across it. Now, they want to try to ruin the fun we all have in ORVs on the beaches. If visitors to the island are not permitted to drive on the beaches, the loss of income for the restaurants, retail shops, rental agencies, property owners, and others that I've not mentioned will be devastating. I can only hope that the federal judge will realize that banning ORV beach access will keep thousands of tourists and fisherman -- and the money they spend – away from Hatteras Island. What a sad day that would be for all of us who love, visit, and live on Hatteras Island.

Sharon Crislip
Fredericksburg, Va.

 
My wife and I have a place in Grandy, N.C. We spend every other weekend in Grandy. We are avid fishermen, and we go to Hatteras just about every time we come down just to fish. We buy all our bait and grub from the village.  We spend a lot of time in Ocracoke also. Please leave our beaches alone

Robert M. Warwick
Crimora, Va.

 
Thanks to everyone out there today. It brought tears to my eyes to see these great people stand up for what they believe in. I sure wish we could have been there. The thought of my grandson not being able to enjoy OBX as we have all these years sickens me. He is only 5 years old but is a true fisherman. Thanks to Free Island Press for keeping us informed.

Beckie Allen
Shelby, N.C.



More on ORV access and lawsuits
 
Being a biologist, and researcher by training, I am often struck by how politics circumvents evidence. Heaven only knows how many plates are being served in this debate, when in actuality there is virtually no hard evidence that the bird and vegetation populations that habituate in the Hatteras area have been negatively affected by the presence of ORVs. There are often many reasons why nesting patterns and dune vegetation patterns change, giving the impression that all is not well in a given environment. Surely, common sense, good judgment and respect for the birds, plants, and dunes, of these sites must be a major consideration and controls with proper violations could and should be enacted.

However, my experiences over the years visiting Hatteras have not revealed any pattern changes that are beyond either (1) a natural course of environment rejuvenation by the species (plant or animal) habitating the areas, or (2) unexplained phenomena not linked to ORVs, primarily present during the summer months, such as feral cats and red fox populations. (See references below.) I say, no evidence, no decisions.

Opinions and trumped up statistics have always been the ploy of advocates for a particular cause to sway opinion of those who, for whatever reason, will not seek out the actual facts. To rob an area by eliminating a wonderful cultural experience to satisfy the needs of those who seek to "save" everything is rather foolish. The financial impact could be catastrophic. Good common sense, awareness of boundaries and limitations are common sense, worthy of a good educational program rather than "stay off" postings.

Knee-jerk philosophies have always proven to be a detriment to success. As a yearly visitor, I sincerely hope the judge in this matter will seek appropriate consultation and make a call based on evidence from both sides, as well as a healthy shot of common sense and future planning for the human as well as other animal and plant species involved.

Click here for references

William Boone
Inman, S.C.


 
I’m just a visitor couple times a year but closing beach access would definitely impact my reasons for visits and bringing my vacation money to Ocracoke.
 
I might have to go to water access by boat to ORV closed sections of the beach and island points.
 
Then the environmentalists would determine that my propeller would be stirring up the surf and cause too much sand to be deposited on the beach and might trip the plover on one of its strolls.
 
I’m an island visitor since 1975.
 
Mark Siess
Gainesville, Va.

 
I've been fishing the surf for years on the Outer Banks. I feel the beach closures are totally unfair to the sportsmen who spend countless dollars to stay in that area, not to speak of the money spent for tackle, food, and fuel. I agree the nesting area should be closed during the season, but to close off all beaches is totally unfair! I guess after all the sportsmen stay clear of the Outer Banks, the bird and turtle watchers will pay the local economy enough to stay alive.

Lynn Doster
Lebanon, Pa.



Hatteras youngsters in mini-musical

Fabulous, fabulous production! I am so impressed. I know some of these children, and I am certain God could not be more pleased with the celebration they gave Him. God bless them all. (Hi, Sam.)

Melinda Ashcraft
Salem, W.Va.

 
I just want say to “thank you” to everyone involved in making this happen. I really enjoyed everything from the practices, the fellowship, and hearing my kids sing day and night. My favorite part was seeing how proud the kids and parents looked during the play. They were truly outstanding. Thanks to all of the parents involved, those behind the scenes, and the United Methodist Women (awsome as usual). Special thanks to Kate Pullen for all of her hardwork and bringing everyone together to make this a huge success. She is a great role model to everyone in the community. I look forward to more plays and musicals. Again, thank you all.

John Fairbanks
Frisco



Life returning to normal on Ocracoke

Jamie Tunnell wrote" Molasses Creek, (www.molassescreek.com) and friends Coyote provided entertainment at the end of the evening with a special rendition of ‘Seven Bridges Road’ by The Eagles."

The song, "Seven Bridges Road," was actually written by and performed by Steve Young, a dynamic musician and songwriter. Check out his music, you'll be glad you did!

Martha Moir
Buxton


 
The song "Seven Bridges Road" was actually written by country music songwriter Steve Young. He actually has an album called "Seven Bridges Road, which was recently repressed. You can buy it here on Amazon.com: http://www.amazon.com/Seven-Bridges-Road-Steve-Young/dp/B000CEWXQI/ref=pd_bbs_sr_4?ie=UTF8&s=music&qid=1205582640&sr=8-4

It's a real shame that more people don't know who he is. Everyone from The Eagles, Waylon Jennings, and Emmylou Harris has played his songs, but unfortunately he remains unknown, even in the South. Steve Young also has a page over on myspace. He still tours and plays live, along with his son Jubal Lee Young. His myspace page is here: http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendid=125812263

I'm glad the bridges were repaired. I know that road took a terrible beating from Hurricane Isabel.
 
Jay Balfe
Plainville, Conn.



Island gardening -- or how to plant stuff in sand

Joy, your column was great. I laughed out loud but did pick up a few ideas. The plastic flowers idea is a stroke of genius. As for all of the stuff in your yard, you may have it over on me in West Virginia. All I have is a broken down VW in my yard.

Debbie Ferri
Fayetteville, W.Va.

 
Great article filled with humor and truisms.

Barbara Madison
Grahamsville, N.Y.




A celebration of beach access at Cape Point

My reasons for this gathering were simple. The local residents and business owners of this island are not different than any American man, woman, or child at this day and time. We worry how we will make our mortgage payment. We worry about job security. We worry about the national economy, and we are worried about our health care. But all of this is being compounded by lawsuits that shouldn't be happening. These are lawsuits that so called "respectable” environmental organizations said they wouldn't file.
 
These organizations gave a good faith agreement to many people to hash out our disagreements among ourselves and they never even gave it a chance.
 
If you read this, Judge Boyle, or anyone else who is undecided on this issue, please do not punish the residents, businesses, and visitors of Hatteras and Ocracoke islands for the mismanagement of the National Park Service for the past 30 years and the dishonorable acts of powerful special interest groups. The Cape Hatteras National Seashore Recreational Area has the best park management it has had in 30 years. Please allow them to do their jobs and encourage all participating groups to negotiate the ORV access issue.
 
Rob Alderman
Buxton


 
My son is in Iraq and will not be home for a year. At that time, I would like to take him and his son (my grandson) to the Outer Banks to enjoy the experiences I have enjoyed with my two brothers, who are now both gone, in the past years, starting in 1968.

Theo McCracken
New Castle, Pa.

 
I come to Hatteras every year with my family. I have two grandsons, ages 3 and 5. I hope that when they are older we give them the same opportunities that we have had over the years. Our grandchildren are the real endangered species on Hatteras Island.

Mike Powers
Coeburn, Va.




One spectator’s view of negotiated rulemaking
 
 
I sat in on the part of the morning sessions both days. You have captured the tension, hope, and enormous frustration really well. I also agree with your take on the facilitators. They really can't handle the group. Process and the agreement on how to discuss and debate issues are very important. If groups believe the process is fair, they will commit to it. Perhaps more important, simply going through the discussions about process can bring a group together. It can build trust and confidence. I don't think the current group has gotten the committee to put aside their policy differences and buy into the process discussions fairly. As you note, there is a lot of posturing and ideology, especially on the environmental side. The business community and the ORV and fishing groups seem to be trying hard to play by the rules, but they are being baited regularly by the "resource groups" and it has to hard not to lash out.
 
Thanks again for the update. You did a great job.

Bob Mueller
Nags Head




Environmental groups ask for beach driving restrictions
 
Until we purchased a four-wheel-drive, we were never able to go on the beach because my husband is handicapped and cannot walk more than a few steps in the sand. The ability to go on the beach, especially to The Point, was liberating!  Often we would just set up our chairs by our Jeep and gaze at the water and the birds for hours. Sometimes I took leisurely strolls to search for shells or just to absorb the beauty. We always obeyed the bird and turtle protective signs. If the beach is closed to vehicular traffic, we will be banished from the beach completely. Is this not public property? Could there not be a permit or payment system developed that would weed out those who disobey the rules? And weren't the local people who gave up their property to create this national seashore promised that they would always have access to it? Or will the government default on its promise?

And if we no longer have access to the beach by vehicle, which is our primary purpose for choosing to stay on Hatteras, we will probably not be returning.

Jeanie Wright
Chesapeake, Va.
 
 

I am handicapped--in a motorized scooter. I was not handicapped when I started coming to Hatteras more than 30 years ago. As an outdoors person who did not eat or smoke myself into my present state (I have multiple sclerosis.), it is disgusting and distressing that some people who say they care want to deny me the access to view nature (Daytona Beach is not nature) in its natural state. Cape Hatteras is the one natural beach that I can be driven in a car on. My husband drives to the water's edge. I have help standing, am put in a chair with my feet in the ocean and a fishing rod in my hand, and I can imagine that for a bit I am like everyone else. Can you even begin to imagine what that feels like?

Hatteras is a national recreation area. Why should I be denied access to it? I worked and paid taxes. My friends and relatives do. I can't hike a dune. I can't chase a bird. I can't reel in much of a fish. But I can sit and watch them.
 
These inhumane people, and they are inhumane, will wake up some day, put on their expensive "vegetarian" shoes (plastic is made from oil, leather from animals--remember), dress up in the latest "outdoor" fad clothing, eat the latest dietary "food," don their imported shades and with water bottle in hand, head out the door to the "private" beach they "won" from the taxpayers of this country. And, if they are over 45 or so, they will discover that they are not what they were when they went to bed. They can't get over the dune! And they can't hike the "private" beach. And someone has taken them to court because they are old and handicapped and "stupid" and want their "stuff" for themselves. And their old age will be worse than it is for people like me, because they did it to themselves.
 
And worst of all, they won't ever be able to see Hatteras again because of what they did in selfishness and stupidity.
 
They didn't pass kindergarten. They don't "play well with others."  Sad.
 
Maybe we all need to join these organizations, elect the officers, give their bank to real environmental needs and thus break their bank. Where do these people get their education? Do they just like to hurt people like me because they can? What do they really want? Who are they and where does their money come from? Can no one help us?

B. Hiscox
Macon, Ga.

 
In this country, there seems to be times for civil disobedience. If these groups prevail, they will be creating a situation where the Cape Hatteras National Recreation Seashore would be in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
 
The suggested action for those of us who are disabled or have family members who are disabled would be to obtain the necessary disabled parking permit and drive on the beach. Enough tickets would be written to be able to get the case to a class action suit against (unfortunately) the National Park Service, Defenders of Wildlife, National Audubon Society, and the Southern Environmental Law Center. I wish I was a lawyer.

Michael Porter
Indianapolis, Ind.

 
I agree with the other readers. The main reason I vacation down there is the freedom of driving on the beach! I do not fish. However, I have enough kites and gear that I cannot carry it all, so I just leave it in the back of my SUV and go. I love going out at 5:30 in the morning and driving over different ramps and exploring and taking pictures. I also agree with the fact that it may not be human error for the decline in shorebirds. There are plenty of fox and wild and domestic cats and dogs that also contribute to the decline. They are hunters. It's a natural for them. For the most part, everyone adheres to the nesting turtle sites and the closures for the birds. I have never seen anyone disobey those closures.

My brother turned me on to driving on the beach.  That's the main reason I bought a vehicle with four-wheel-drive. I immediately fell in love with it! I, for one, will not come back down there to vacation if I can not drive on the beach! I think a lot of people feel the same way. The economy of the Outer Banks will go downhill!

Annette Stokes
Colonial Heights, Va.

 
 
My family has been coming down to Hatteras for more than 20 years. We finally purchased a home three years ago for our grandchildren’s enjoyment. Their favorite part of the trip each year is to be able to drive on the beach and see all the birds/turtles nesting. We have brought up our children and now grandchildren to learn and respect the environment and the animals that live on the shoreline. Don't take this away from us please.

Adam Cross
Egg Harbor Township, N.J.

 
We have about six families that come down year round and spend our money on shopping and going to beaches to go fishing, and if they close it down, we will not be coming down to the Outer Banks anymore. I know that we need more careful driving on the beach for the birds, but there are more people killed on the roads for accidents than birds on the beach, so what should we do? Close all the highways down also? No, just like driving on the roads, we need to be more careful.

Hope to enjoy many more years of fishing on the Outer Banks.

Chip Illian
Millsboro, Del.

 
I wonder what the governor would say if the mid-Currituck bridge was no longer needed because there weren't enough folks coming to the Outer Banks?
 
Imagine the loss to Currituck, Dare, and Hyde Counties in money if the volume of visitors was reduced 25 or 35 or 50 percent because of the loss of beach access. Is the governor willing to cancel the bridge being built if its no longer needed? Think about the jobs and money generated in northeast North Carolina.

Mike Metzgar
Roaring Spring, Pa.
 
If 50 percent of the visitors going to Cape Hatteras National Seashore and the eight villages decided that without beach access, they weren't coming for vacation, how much traffic would there be on the Wright Memorial Bridge? Would the pressure on Highway 12 north to Corolla be reduced to a trickle?
 
Think about the financial trickle down effect on all three counties.
 
To all our friends in the villages, as members of NCBBA, as visitors to Hatteras Island for 30-plus years, and as parents of children who were taught conservation and respect for the park by the likes of Rany Jennette, Warren Wrenn, and others of the same ilk, we are committed to open beach access and will support and defend that right however we are able.
 
Mike and Patti Metzgar
Roaring Spring, Pa.




A time of celebration and sadness for a Hatteras family  

God blessed us with twins, one in Heaven and one on Earth. We rejoice in the birth of Joseph Daniel Kavanagh IV. Born February 19, 2008.  5 pounds 14 1/2 ounces - 19 3/4 inches.
 
And are deeply saddened by the passing of his twin brother, Lee Perry Kavanagh. Stillborn February 19, 2008.
 
We are grateful to Dr. Winfree and Dr. Dwyer and the staff at Coastal Women's Clinic and Outer Banks Hospital for their dedication and compassion.  We thank you, our family and friends, near and far, for your love and support during this time of joy and sorrow.
 
Jay and Natalie Kavanagh
Dan and Regena Kavanagh
Bryan and Susie Perry




Guest Column: One spectator’s view of negotiated rulemaking

 
Thank you so much for all of this important information. The public really needs to know more about everything that concerns us all.
 
Thank you again for all of your effort.

Debbie Powers
Goodview, Va.


 
We have visited the Frisco area at least once a year since 1980 and found it the last area of reasonable and cooperative beach freedom in the world. It tears my heart to see so many attempts to destroy this, mostly by people and organizations who have never been there and will never be there and whose only purpose is to follow their own special interests without regard to the feelings and interests of those whose home it is. What is more important -- the lifestyle, economy, and businesses of the residents or a bird’s nest? A bird can always find another place to live - not so with long-term residents.
 
These people have lived here for many years and have taken upon themselves to preserve the area despite all the garbage brought by visitors.

They have done well.  Leave them alone.  If ORV access is prohibited or vastly curtailed, I, and many others will have no reason to go there. There are thousands of other beaches with their swarms of restrictions and shoulder-to-shoulder people. I have a swimming pool at home!

Harry Porter
Sun City Center, Fla.




Oh, say, have you seen?

This United States flag at National Park Service headquarters at the Cape Hatteras Light Station is tattered and torn. It is the symbol of our country, and it is a disgrace that the Park Service displays the flag in this matter. Given the condition of this flag, I understand why the Park Service does not illuminate it at night, as is required by the United State of America Flag Code.

Ben Doerr
Avon
 




Supporting commercial fishermen

I would encourage every citizen on the coast of North Carolina to take note of the plight of our commercial fishermen. It is just another example of the little guy being put out of business by politicians’ affiliation with special interest groups, such as the Coastal Conservation Association. People come from all over the country to vacation along the Outer Banks and a part of that appeal is their ability to buy fresh seafood.

There are those who are committed to shutting Hatteras Island down, by cutting off our beaches to the public and sending our fishermen into extinction. If we’re not diligent, our commercial fishermen will live only through stories taught to our children.

We need to take aim at those who set policy. With 2008 being an election year, we’re presented with an opportunity to replace those members of the state legislature, the United States House of Representatives, and U.S. Senate who work against those whose only fault is honest living and hard work.

Kevin Conner
Hatteras




Great Backyard Bird Count
 
I was glad to see Island Free Press coverage of the Great Backyard Bird Count this year. In looking at the North Carolina tallies, I could see that more bird lists were submitted from the Outer Banks this year, thanks to you. I've done GBBC for several years. It's fun, it will encourage you to learn to identify more birds in your backyard, and it requires a minimum of only 15 minutes to observe. Even if you didn't submit a bird list this year, you can go to the Web site, go to North Carolina in the state tallies, and see the specific species were identified this year in Hatteras, Frisco, Buxton, etc. There is a reason that North Carolina is second only to New York in the number of lists submitted each year. Put it on your calendar for next February!

Elizabeth Browning Fox
Chapel Hill



Environmental groups ask for beach driving restrictions
 
I am very depressed about this situation and the way that this is going down – or rather, the way we allowed it to happen.
 
Most locals seem to have no idea about this and act if it's something new, but it has been going on for years. How is that possible? While there are a lot of people who have been involved and have fought hard locally, there is not even 1 percent of the business owners or residents who have been very outspoken at the public comment periods or inquiries.
 
The money that it has taken to do most of the fighting up to this point has mainly come from the visitor donations and their seeming desire to keep our beaches open -- more than most locals. God forbid we wanted to serve a mixed drink.  Then there would be people lining the streets, billboards, and a screaming public outcry.
 
Well, those who haven't taken time out of their busy schedules to get involved and learn the issues are about to have plenty of time on their hands, and I am sure they will be crying -- just not in public.
 
Many thanks to those businesses, locals, tourists, and Dare County officials who have fought, donated, and tried to spread the word.

Rob Alderman
http://www.fishmilitia.com
Buxton




My wife and I own and operate the Old Gray House Gift Shop, Inc., located in Buxton on Cape Hatteras Island.  We would like to take this opportunity to give our assessment of how we feel a ruling to stop beach driving in the Cape Hatteras National Park will affect the local economy, as well as the general welfare of the public.

t is our honest opinion that to discontinue beach driving will devastate not only our business but many others as well.  The majority of those who patronize our business come to the Island for the joy of being able to drive on the beach.  They are conservative, family-oriented people who come to the island annually to fish, collect shells, or just spend a relaxing day at Cape Point and the South Beach.
 
The nature of our business is such that we have a very close relationship with those who come to our shop.  They have indicated to us that should there be a ban on beach driving, they would have no reason to continue coming to Hatteras Island.    We can attest to how the sudden, short-term closure of Cape Point in 2005 affected some of our regulars and caused a slump in our business that year.  Their contention was “Why should I pay thousands of dollars to come here if I no longer have the freedom to drive the beach and fish?”  Some were so upset that they vowed never to return to the island, and thus far they never have.  We not only lost revenue, but friends as well. We feel the national publicity from a ban on beach driving will cause many people to avoid coming to the Outer Banks this coming season. 

What many forget is that the structure of what generates our island economy is entirely different from other beach areas.  Vacationers who come to Hatteras Island do not come here for the usual razzmatazz you find in the majority of the tourist areas.  They come here for the beach and nothing else.  Our image is that of an open beach with small fishing villages entwined in a national park.  Visitors come here to be in tune with the forces of nature and the history and culture of the Island.  If you remove the freedom to drive and roam the beach, you remove the unique lure of Hatteras.
 
We question why the businesses and people of Hatteras Island should be punished by banning beach driving because of the inaction of the National Park Service to have put a proper beach driving plan in place years ago.  It would appear to us that now, when they are attempting to rectify the situation, there would not be any limiting of beach driving, but applauding them for finally doing what they should have done years ago. To ban beach driving at this time is counter-productive.  The Park Service is working with the public and its rules negotiation committee to come up with a plan that will protect the animal and plant and animal life, and the public’s recreational interests as well. 

We are sure, if given the opportunity without interference from outside interests, the Park Service and the public will come up with a plan to satisfy all concerned.

Mary and Dewey Parr
Buxton 



 
My family and I have been spending our vacation for the last 12 years on Hatteras Island, enjoying the surf fishing away from what most people call "the beach." So go ahead and stop the one thing that means the most to my family and friends, as well as the people who have lived there all their life. You might as well set saw horses across Highway 12 at Nags Head and let the birds have the island. I understand the habitat for the birds, but how about the habitat for the people who love to go the beach and not see a Wal-Mart or a 10-mile traffic jam? Why can't we just leave some things as they are?
 
So close the beach and I'll never come again.
 
Thanks from a person who loves your island and the people who live there.
 
Dusty Lowe
Mount. Airy, N.C.



As a former law enforcement ranger at Cape Hatteras National Seashore, I hope the current superintendent will allow access to all locals in their autos.

Tim Kruzer
Cleveland, Ohio



I would like to voice my strong concerns about the recent move to possibly close some beaches to ORVs on Hatteras Island and Ocracoke. I have been coming to the island for the past 36 years. We have bought and sold property there and currently own a home on the sound. I think this decision would be a devastating blow to the economy of the area and would be a huge blow to the tourist population who visit there every year.

I agree that we should respect and take care of the birds, wildlife, flora, and dunes on Hatteras Island. That is the reason we drive seven hours from our home in West Virginia to be there. It is a beautiful area and we love being there. It is part of our family's life to come to Hatteras. Driving on the beaches is part of being there, too. We have always taken our ORV on the beach, and we have been very careful to respect the areas that are roped off for wildlife protection.

If folks could not drive on the beaches, you would have cars parked for miles and miles along Highway 12, walking over the beautiful dunes, disturbing the wildlife and the flora of the dunes. It would be the longest parking lot in the state of North Carolina. I can't imagine a more horrible thing to do. Surf fishing is what we do when we come to Hatteras, and most of the areas we surf fish are not accessible if you can't drive on the beach. This area has never been like other beaches - Ocean City, etc. - and that's why folks keep coming back to it! Surf fishing is a big economic industry to the local towns. If you take away the beach driving, you take away the income of many of the local merchants.

This entire situation was being handled in a very diplomatic process and because one or two groups who oppose ORVs on the beach decide to bypass the diplomatic route, the economy of a wonderful area of North Carolina could seriously be hurt. Talk about hurting the birds!  This would be a hundred times more devastating.  This could destory the economic base of the entire island

 I hope you receive many e-mails concerning this situation. This will have a far reaching effect.  Folks come from all over the world to vacation on Hatteras Island, and most come because of access to the beaches and good fishing. Thanks for giving me a chance to voice my concerns.

Betty Russell
Martinsburg, W.Va.


 
We and our extended family have been visitors to your island since the late ‘50s. We enjoyed the access to your beaches for fishing, swimming and relaxing. I think that we will not make any plans for 2008 until you resolve your problems.

R.H. Oster
Trafford, Pa.


I’ve been spending tourist dollars two or three times a year on the Banks for 20 years. I (we) even turned relatives on to the beauty. Never once have we done anything that might even be construed as detrimental to the environment. I don't know what we can do to help, but I'll offer anything I can. The beach driving has always been the draw for us. My kids grew up on it, and if they were asked where they wanted to go on vacation, they would tell you OBX. What a shame some people have nothing better to do than ruin someone else's vacation. I really think some of these folks don't have a life and can't stand to see someone else having a good time. Please put up the best fight you can. If there's anything we here in the Buckeye can do, feel free.
 
Jeff Sliger
Akron,Ohio



After reading the transcripts from the first court appearance this morning, I have been in a real funk all day. I keep having pictures flash through my mind of the early ‘80s and my little girls running around the Point or the inlet in diapers and nothing else. I see them asleep on "their bed" in the back of the truck after a full day of playing on the beach. I see my son, who is now 19, with his fishing pole at the tip of the inlet, when he was 2 years old -- and both of my boys running around the Point all day when they were 6 and 2 with their plastic Blackbeard swords playing "NoBeard the Pirate." I have pictures of my now 22-year-old lying on her back at Point where the shallow water would wash over her from two directions. She thought it was the greatest thing she had ever seen or felt in her life! She was 3.

The family memories we have made on those beaches over the last 20-plus years will never be equaled and never be replaced. And it breaks my heart that now that my children are getting to the age that they may have kids in the near future, I won't be able to take my grandchildren to those special places and do those special things and raise them as little beach bums like my kids were. They would play all day and then I'd take them down to the edge of water, usually in the hook where it was calmer, and wash the sand off of them one at a time. Then I would carry them back to the vehicle, give them a clean diaper and a snack, and lay them down on their foam mattress to sleep while we fished well into the night. I have pictures of each of them at one time or another asleep on a beach towel under the shade of the tailgate of the truck. I just realized, that I hear opponents saying they are so afraid of the ORVs and the safety issues for their children on the beach. Goodness, mine were never NOT around the vehicles at the inlet or the Point and I never worried about them.

I remember that as my girls got older and were really into fast-pitch softball and my sons were playing baseball, we would take gloves and bats and balls on vacation. One time we had a huge softball game out at the Point that got people from five or six other groups involved. As a result, we met some people from West Virginia whose daughters also played travel softball, and we later ran into them at a tournament in Chattanooga, Tenn. How's that for making friends? There was this one family from somewhere in New Jersey (I can still remember their names -- the Taglianetis, probably not spelled right.) that vacationed with their children the same weeks we did every year. Our daughters wrote to each other during the year and couldn't wait to get back to Hatteras every summer to see each other again. We would always end up parked beside them at the Point that week.

And, oh, the bluefish blitz! One year in the late fall, we took the girls who were probably 6 and 4 or so down to camp at Hatteras Sands Campground. We hit it just right and got into a blue blitz at the inlet. The girls were playing in the back of this old Nissan pick-up that we bought solely for the purpose of Hatteras trips. The fish were running up the beach, and my husband caught and walked with them for several miles back toward Ramp 55. I would hop in the truck and drive on up the beach with the girls when he got almost out of sight. That may have been the best fishing day ever.

And for those of you who have an OBPA calendar, check out November. That's my son down at Hatteras Inlet. He hooked a huge ray that afternoon. It took him miles (it seemed like miles, at least) up the beach from near the bird closure at the tip almost back to the ramp. He fought that thing for almost two hours. My husband kept telling him he should just break it off because he thought it was a ray, but Jake kept saying, "It's got head bob. It's a cobia Dad, I know it!" So we followed him -- the 14-year-old boy and his fish. He would get so far up the beach, with his Dad and uncle beside him, that the moms would have to go back and get the vehicles and move them on up. He eventually drew a crowd of onlookers from other vehicles. Everyone was cheering for the kid and his big fish. He never gave up, and he never gave up the fishing rod even when his arms were almost dead from the exertion. He finally got it to the beach and everyone cheered for him. He was so proud. Guess what? It wasn't even a cobia, but it didn't matter. He had fought the beast and defeated it. He got a little closer to being a man that day.

My children grew up to love and respect Hatteras Island -- everything about it, as a matter of fact. They are familiar with its history and its culture. They know about the National Seashore Recreation Area, they know about the history and importance of charter fishing, and they know about and respect the commercial fishermen. They learned from the time they were old enough to walk and talk that you never throw your trash down on the beach and you always fill in the holes that you dig. They learned to drive on the beach as soon as they had their North Carolina permits. They know all about airing down and staying in the ruts and not driving in the red sand. And they know about the island in the off-season when it's mostly only the fishermen who keep the island's economy going. In fact, if not for the off-season trips we made, my oldest daughter, who lives in Hatteras village now, would not have met the young man she loves and with whom she plans her future, because he's a local charter fisherman that she first met on a striper trip we booked.

To think that I will never sit on the tip of the Point and watch the sunset again or follow one of my kids or grandkids down the beach while they fight the epic battle is the most heartbreaking thing I've had to deal with in a long time. I had sort of hoped to take my grandkids some day down to the edge of the water and wash them off at the end of a long day on the beach, and put them to sleep in the back of the Suburban, while I watched the sunset with my children (their parents) and reminisced. I am very afraid that this is not going to be the case, and it feels like a death, the loss is so acute.

If it doesn't happen, if the inlet and the Point are not closed to ORVs, I will be happy to acknowledge that I assumed the worst and others can accuse me of over-reacting. But I feel it has come to an end. And it was one of the most important things in my and my family's life. I will miss it more than any of you can begin to imagine, unless you've been there right beside me, and I firmly believe that my grandchildren will be the poorer for not having seen it and lived it.

Renee Tomberlin
Burnsville, N.C.



I think the environmental groups opposing ORV use on the beach should have to provide strong proof of damage to the environment in order to stop ORV use.  That’s one of the major draws to any fishing area, including right here in Delaware.  Being able to drive your four-wheel-drive onto the beach, pulling out your beach chairs, fishing rods and tackle boxes and rod holder, setting up and fishing is a major outing if you have to carry all that out on foot.  It would take way too many trips.

The first time we came to Hatteras, I did not have a four-wheel-drive vehicle.  I parked in a lot and loaded myself up and walked out to the Point to fish.  It was gruesome. I had to keep stopping to rest every now and then.

This could ruin your spot as a vacation destination for many people.  I met a few people from Virginia Beach on several occasions who also came down for vacation simply just to drive onto the beach and fish.  If they want to regulate racing on the beach or something of that nature, I might be inclined to lean their way, but this whole thing seems stupid.  I can’t believe there’s no fishermen’s association down there fighting this.  It’s just another case of government telling us what’s best for us, like we’re idiots.

Yes, we are idiots for putting them where they are.  Put them back in the private sector and see how long they last.

Neil Donovan
Wilmington, Del.

 
I knew this is what they were going to do – wait and buy time by acting like they wanted to be part of a process. Then just as spring approaches, they close the beaches and mess over everybody. These are some people with no decency no morals and no brains.

Denny Gray
Dayton, Ohio

 
My family owns a home in Avon. One of the reasons for picking this area was the ability to drive onto the beach. Our sons fish year round here on the Point and look forward to bringing their four-wheel-drive vehicles for this. As we age, the convenience of not having to walk long distances to the beach is a must. Another large concern is the plummeting of property values when this information hits the general public. Our investment will become a nightmare.

Rhonda Wesley
Richmond, Va.

 
I expected nothing less from these environmental groups’ actions. Suing is the only way these groups know how to get things their strict way, absolutely no compromise.

Rob Alderman
Buxton



As a born-and-bred resident and fan of the Outer Banks of North Carolina, I am extremely upset by this. My biggest personal issue is the failure of these groups to understand this land was created as a recreational park, meaning for the enjoyment of humans! This is not a National Park.
 
I would like to go on record here and remind the Defenders of Wildlife and the National Audubon Society that there is no such thing as the Cape Hatteras National Seashore. You will find no government title, deed, grant, or other reference to this fictitious piece of property. The true name of the location in question is the Cape Hatteras National Seashore Recreational Area, specifically designated by the United States Congress to be utilized for the purpose of human recreation in all its forms.
 
This needs to be fought hard and fast before its too late to repair the damage these groups are about to do to our traditions, our heritage, our rights to enjoy our park, and the severe economic impact this decision would have on the areas that surround this little piece of sand.
 
As a member of the North Carolina Beach Buggy Association, but not on behalf of that group, I would like to direct your attention to a forum it has created to discuss this issue and its impacts. The address of the forum is: http://ncbba.powweb.com/buggyboard//viewforum.php?f=7
 
I hope you will publish this and help make people more aware of the consequences this will have on our Outer Banks.
 
Tommy Jordan
Greenville, N.C.



The state will lose a lot of tax dollars if the beaches are closed. Everybody suffers from that. Keep the beaches open and free!

I wonder how many people in these environmental groups wear gold, silver, and gems. If any do, they should not proclaim to be an environmentalist. Do they think of the land and habitats destroyed in this process, not to include the lives lost? I agree some protection may be needed, but an out right ban is not necessary.

Sharon Peele Kennedy
Buxton



The state will lose a lot of tax dollars if the beaches are closed. Everybody suffers from that. Keep the beaches open and free!

Joe Bough
Bridgeville, Del.
 
 

I and my family have been coming to the Outer Banks for more than 25 years. Although we do not live on the Banks year round, we have recently obtained a trailer in Buxton. I feel that I have been a Banker for these 25 years and have gone from the vacationer to the walk-on fisherman to the owner of a four-wheel-drive for fishing. I am slightly handicapped with a bum leg and getting on the beach is made easier with the truck. In the time I have been there for these past 25 years, I have seen nothing but respect for the environment and its species of all kinds from the fishing community.
 
To have outsiders and people that do no respect the area is going to happen. That is why we have the park rangers to control these lawbreakers. The fishing community in itself also tries to police the wrong doers and reports to the rangers when violations occur. To close the Banks to the ORV is outrageous. In the long run, the money of the big business and the developers will take away all that belongs to the people of the United States and will have no regard for turtles or birds, should they be in the way of new condos, stores, or parking lots. Look at the oceanside in Virginia Beach and you see what the Banks will be in the coming years if this is allowed to go on.

I have no problem with rules and regulations. I feel we all have to live by them, but I will not stand by and let the "big money business guys" control a resource to which I am entitled and have paid my dues to enjoy.  I respect it, I love it, and I will fight to defend these rights.

Robert Crelin
Neptune, N.J.



I fail to see how closing the beaches "temporarily" is going to help anyone other than the organizations that would rather the residents of Hatteras Island be removed and the whole island be given to birds and turtles. It doesn't seem that the seasonal nesting of these particular animals is even being taken into consideration. Organizations such as The Defenders of Wildlife and the National Audubon Society would like nothing more than to close our beaches right before tourist season and send a blow to the gut of the residents who so much rely on it. If that happens, they will then focus their finances and efforts toward the beaches, staying that way until the issue is resolved. Dealing with the National Park Service is not ever going to be fast process and making the residents pay for it is not the way to help the birds and turtles. If they want to help nature on Hatteras, maybe these organizations could pay off the insurance money on the first three condemned houses on Mirlo Beach and demolish them before all those poor little birds and turtles have to deal with the rubble.

I'm no head of any multi-million dollar society, but it seems like the money and efforts wasted in courts could be focused more effectively. Closing the beaches is not going to make anything go faster. What are the goals here? Birds and turtles? A piece of paper with regulations that will not be enforced? I watch the current rules and regulations get ignored time and time again. Nobody from the National Audubon Society is ever around to write tickets to the kids stomping on the dunes or the dogs that run down the beaches. They don’t even live here.

Tracy Morris
Frisco

 


Rather than waiting for the NegReg process to work out a consensus ORV plan, this is just another example of a bunch of wacko environmentalists gone berserk in pursuing their own agenda to the detriment of all the taxpaying public users of the Cape Hatteras National RECREATIONAL Seashore!


William I. Berryhill, Jr.
Chief United States Marshal, Ret.
Eastern District of North Carolina



It's no longer a free country. Instead of man having dominion over the earth and creatures, it looks like a few birds have taken over the beach. What is the judge going to do about the predatory creatures that eat those bird eggs? He should try to ban them from the beach also.

Steve Blaisdell/ Broker Associate
Beach Realty and Construction


 
As a property owner who spends summers and spring on Hatteras, it doesn't surprise me to see the issue of beach driving become a big issue. Between the bridge and the beach driving and all the stall tactics that are being done, it will be amazing that anyone who depends on vacationers will make any money to stay on the island. The last person to move off the island better take the bridge with him.  All these special interest groups better be careful or there will not be any island to worry about because there won't be anyone there. But that just may make them happy.

Why is it that no one can make a final decision on anything that affects the big issues facing Hatteras Island?

Roger Marsh
Plantation, Fla.



Thanks for covering this, and I say "HURRAY!" Twelve percent is a very modest amount of beach to set aside for these breeding shorebirds in 2008. I hope the judge acts promptly to protect the birds.

Annie Runyon
Garner, N.C.


We have been visitors to Ocracoke Island since early in the 1960s.  We have long enjoyed being able to take our fishing gear out to the beach instead of carrying it over the dunes.  We feel that we are very aware of the wildlife on the island, but we think since tourism is the largest profit for the island, ORV use should be reviewed. I am now handicapped and can no longer walk over the dunes. let alone walk in the sand.  But I still enjoy fishing.  So how will I be allowed to continue enjoying what we like? 
 
Saving the wildlife is very important, but I think the island also needs the tourism traffic to continue to be able to pay taxes as we do.
 
Sonja Maynor
Asheboro, N.C.

 
To start off, I’m a fisherman. I've never run over a bird, turtle, or a mouse on the beach! I always take more trash off the beach than I take on the beach. So if they are going to stop me from driving on the beach, they need to stop all the netters. They are capturing turtles in there nets. Oh, yes, what about the seagulls eating the eggs? What about the foxes killing the bird, and the cats eating those poor little endangered mice? Let’s point your fingers where they deserve to be, not on the fishermen.

Darrell Worley

Hopewell, Va.

 

Keep Beach driving legal!


Matt Tempesco
Virginia Beach




Lady Canes in the playoffs

Our crowd here at Hatteras was a great sixth man, and it would be a real plus to bring some of that energy to Greenville to support our girls. Congratulations to Coach Fountain, but mostly to a group of determined young ladies of whom we are very proud.

Danny Couch
Buxton


Way to go, girls.  Keep it up and good luck.

Wilhelmina Grubbs
Rodanthe

 
I appreciate the fine, posted pictures of the game with the Lady Lakers. I'm Paxton Gwin's proud uncle, her Dad Steve's big brother. Steve sent me several blurred pictures taken with a cheap camera. I razzed him about it, and he sent me your link. Great shots. Thanks. Go Canes!

William L. Gwin
King George, Va.


Congratulations to the Lady Hurricanes and best of luck as you advance through the play-offs!

Renee Tomberlin
Burnsville, N.C.




Ocracoke Update
 

Yeah to my mom for being such a hard worker and making sure the mail gets there! She's great!

Lauren Fulcher
Ocracoke



Environmental groups ask for beach driving restrictions
 
Elitist environmental groups will never come to the table in good faith. The issue is in the courts now and will still be in the courts even after all negotiated rulemaking is over. These social engineers  survive only by the courts.

Bob Lick
Cheyenne, Wyo.


All this talk about restricting "only" 12 percent more land from ORV use is crazy. I just can't imagine not being able to drive out to the Outer Banks and fish at Cape Point. It's like saying we are only going to cut off your hand -- after all it's only 1 percent of your body!

Peter McGrain
Rocky Mount, N.C.


As long as the seashore is a unit of the National Park Service, it is subject to the same management standards as a National Park, no matter what you call it. See this link http://www.nps.gov/legacy/nomenclature.html.

If you don't want Cape Hatteras National Seashore managed as a part of this agency, then lobby to have it removed -- and all that comes with it, because it will become private land and you won't be able to access the Point because it will become someone's private yard. That’s the way it was when the Phelps family owned it before they donated it to the NPS.

Tyler Smith
Cincinnati, Ohio

 
If this injunction happens, I will be canceling my two-week vacation in Frisco. There is no reason to go to Hatteras Island if I can't drive on the beach with my family or drive on to fish as I want. Too bad it has come to this.
 
Tom Carr
Wilmington, Del.



Valentine’s Day greetings

My husband, Kevin Feese, who wrote the story, "A Hatteras Love Story," is the most loving and caring husband. I wish I would have thought to write something about him. That's the way Kev is -- very thoughtful and sweet. No, you can't have him! He's mine, forever!

Debra Feese
Annandale, Va.

 
Very nicely done. Lots of love here, and it's good to show it to everyone. Thanks.

Ed Rebstock
Salvo


 
The seal swim

 
My niece in Buxton told me of your Web site. What a great event to raise money for a cause.  I did enjoy looking at Russ Kiddy. He appears to be having at great time

Pancheta Scammell
Melbourne Beach, Fla.


I commend Kathy Kiddy on a great idea for our area. Best of luck with participation!

Lorraine Burrus
Hatteras



Hatteras Island Real Estate
 
In response to Tom Hranicka's recent articles on Hatteras real estate, I'd like to offer the following thoughts from one prospective buyer sitting on the sidelines.

Hatteras Island has always been very special to me. My maternal grandmother was a Scarborough from Ocracoke and her husband, a Foster from Hatteras. It feels like "home" to me.

I've been following the real estate market on Hatteras Island closely for the last eight months, with the intention of purchasing a cottage. My husband and I owned a cottage in Avon for several years, but reluctantly sold it to finance college educations for our twin sons. We thought at the time that we would most likely never again be able to afford to purchase another home on the island. However, we are now in a position to do so, but have some reservations.

I agree that it appears to be a good time to buy, but there are some considerations. Many of the homes we are looking at were purchased only a few years ago and are listed at three times the purchase price paid by the current owners. I have not seen the 44 percent reduction in median selling prices cited in the article and, in my mind, it's tough to justify paying the inflated prices. Unless there is a very significant down payment, the rental income will not come close to covering expenses, which is a consideration for us. We're not wealthy people, we just want a little piece of Hatteras on which to retire.

Another issue to consider is the very real threat of the effects of global warming on Hatteras. I don't want my retirement home to be under water in 10, 15, or 20 years.
Interest rates are low, but might go lower. Every little reduction helps.

I have enjoyed reading Tom Hranicka's articles over the years and have found him to be most informative. I purchased his book years ago before we bought our cottage, and it was very helpful. I look forward to his continued updates. Despite all of my concerns, I hope to find that perfect beach cottage on Hatteras very soon.

Karen Murray
Pipersville, Pa.



Remembering Dale Burrus

 
We just learned of Dale's passing yesterday, Feb. 16. We met Dale back in the ‘70s during our first trip to Hatteras village. A year or two later, we had rented a place in Nags Head for a week. My husband had talked to Dale, who was having trouble getting someone to trim the feet of his ponies. My husband was a farrier and he took his shoeing equipment and during that vacation he went on down to Hatteras to trim Dale's ponies. In 1990, we bought a condo at Sea Whisper in Hatteras village.  Dale was our first visitor. We would always stop by the store when we were in town, and if Dale was there, he always took time to talk for a few minutes. We sold our place several years ago, so it has been awhile since we had seen Dale.
 
He was always a kind and caring man. To Lorraine and her family, all we can say is that we are so very sorry for your loss. Hatteras is a better place because of Dale Burrus.

Skip and Joy Taylor
Yorktown, Va.




Molly the pig has a new home

Thank you all so much for all the help and concern and good thoughts that went toward finding Molly a new, safe home.  I just delivered her to some wonderful people in southern Maryland, and Molly appeared to settle into the barn (once we got her in it!) and her new family quite well.  She was a trooper -- nearly an eight-hour ride without a bit of complaint. 
Bless you all and thank you again from Molly and myself.

Catherine Jones
Rodanthe

(Editor’s note:  Molly is an 18-month old pot-bellied pig who was rescued by her owners and put on a diet.  She was doing well on Hatteras but needed a home with more space and safety than living on Highway 12 afforded her. Her owners’ plea for a new home has been included in the Island Free Press classified ads for some weeks.  We’re happy the story had a happy ending. 



Concerns about former motel property
 
As a property owner and long-time visitor to Hatteras village, I am deeply troubled by the condition of the property that once was the General Mitchell Motel -- not only  this property but also the old Pelican Roost property that was demolished and piled up in a heap of rubble and left to blow around since last summer. I spend at least two months a year in Hatteras, and it bothers me to see such a beautiful place left in this condition. How do the year round residents feel and why aren't they as upset as I am?

I have written a letter to all the Dare County Board of Commissioners and to state Sen. Marc Basnight. asking for their help in resolving this serious situation. I know how the General Mitchell Motel was constructed, and I was told by the North Carolina EPA that a permit was never issued for demolition. All the hazardous material that was in the debris was ground up and put into a huge pile and left to blow around.  How can this be allowed to happen?

William Goodman



Thinking of Richie and Nikki Spears

I read The Island Free Press whenever you send it. I was looking at the classified ads and saw that the Hatteras Sushi Company was selling its equipment, so I looked further. I saw the story on Richie Spears and was shocked to read that he has non-Hodgkins lymphoma.

I remember both Richie and Nikki from when our family visited Hatteras two years ago. We had just gotten a huge amount of flounder and needed them cleaned and filleted. My wife volunteered me, and Richie offered to do it for a couple bucks! He was a real lifesaver at that moment. He invited us to the restaurant to pick them up later. We fell in love with the place and spent several more nights there.

We went there our last night on Hatteras, and I remember purchasing a large amount of sushi, while my wife chatted with Nikki. It was one of my favorite nights I've spent on the island.

Is there anything more you can tell me about his condition? We think of
them often and have nothing but good thoughts and feelings when we do.
I was thinking about using him this year to do some crabbing and fishing  with our kids when we come down.

I hope and pray he's recovering. If possible, please let me know how they both are doing.

Todd Maihle
Mount Airy, Md.

(Editor’s note:  Richie Spears is undergoing cancer treatment at Duke University Medical Center in Durham. For cards or letters, their address is P.O. Box 313, Hatteras, NC 27943.)



Solving the mystery of the SS Chester Sun

Please advise Hal Shelton that, first, he wrote a wonderful article and also that "Teddy" Mutro, a great friend of mine in Ocracoke, found it amusing that he was referred to as "the late Theodore Mutro."

The “still present" Randy Jordan
Buxton

(Editor’s Note.  The editor apologizes to Mr. Mutro.  It was her error, the result of a misunderstanding, and not Mr. Shelton’s mistake.)




Seals on the beach
 
God's timing is so good! Thank-you, Island Free Press, for covering the seals on the beach. It is the perfect story to introduce Locomotion's "Seal Swim" on Saturday, March 1.

Kathy Kiddy
Locomotion director
Buxton




Five reasons why winter is great on Hatteras
 
Just thought you'd like to know that the line that is quoted in this article, "If you don't have anything nice to say about someone, sit right next to me," was originally said by Alice Roosevelt, Teddy's daughter.

Timothy Tietze
Chester Spring, Pa.



Old Christmas

 
We loved the Old Christmas article, as we have heard so much about the event. And the pictures by Amberly and Jon are fantastic. We saw a number of familiar faces, including our Robin!

Claude LeSieur
Lewes, Del.



I went to Old Christmas last year with my dear friend, Carey LeSieur, and her husband Robin. It was fun to see the slide show and read Amberly's article on this year's party. The oysters were delicious and after hearing about this festive occasion for so many years, I am glad I had a chance to go to be with all the wonderful Hatteras Island friends.
 
Cecily Patterson
Portland, Ore.



Honoring Mary Helen

I have lived on Hatteras Island all of my life (except for four years spent blissfully at UNC-CH). I have met and known many dedicated and wonderful volunteers. Of all of them, you are the most tireless person I have even known.
 
Advocacy for our island's many issues is a wonderful, rewarding quest, which has burned out many amazing people. You, Mary-Helen, are an inspiration to me. My husband and I are raising our small family and trying to stay involved in the community and school. There are many days when I shake my head and wonder if the effort is worth it.
 
On those days, I think of you, and know the effort is always worth the result. Thank you for the guidance you have given me and for being such an amazing inspiration to us all.

Jennifer Johnson
Hatteras


We are so thankful for Mary Helen. Through the years she has done a wonderful job reporting the news of Hatteras Island. We appreciate her dedication to the reporting of events at Cape Hatteras Secondary School. We have also enjoyed the many photo collages she has made of Hatteras Island’s children, while they were at school. God Bless you, Mary Helen. Keep up the good work!

Donna and Phil Tokazowski
Hatteras


Congratulations, Mary Helen. You have been a pearl to Hatteras Island and Dare County. I came to Hatteras in 1995 to assist Cape Hatteras Electric Co-op. We had many problems -- poor service to our user owners and poor customer communications. I met you my first day when your were covering a board meeting at CHEC. You became a great friend and one who had great journalism skills in writing about issues on Hatteras Island. I listened to you and others on Hatteras Island and worked on your suggestions on how we could improve our service, communications, and customer service.
You have made a difference, and we all thank you. I wish I could have been present the day you were honored.

Jim Sherfey
Tampa, Fla.


Not only does Mary Helen do great justice for the people of Hatteras Island, she breaks the barrier across the Hatteras Inlet to help out the people of Ocracoke. It has been my pleasure to see her in action on the Scenic Byway Advisory Committee for Dare, Hyde, and Carteret. A great lady and leader for our communities!

Jamie Tunnell
Ocracoke




Ocracoke Updates

We just wish we were there right now. We can handle driving on the beach since we do a lot of it while we are there. We will be glad to be back in a few months and see the end-project.

Tim and Lisa White
Morganton, N.C.


I remember the Pub when it was established by the original owner, Ron Howard. The one-room building was a great place to kick back and enjoy the atmosphere. I spent many a night polishing the copper-topped bar for a free beer, depending on who was bar tending. It was quite crowded with 20 people back then. I can’t imagine what it's expanded to now. I served in the U.S. Coast Guard and was stationed on the island from 1987-1991. Anyone from that era who remembers me, please give a shout at slthompson@panax.com

I hope to get back to visit some day. I hope the traditions of the island don't change too much, as the locals depended on driving the beach as their way of life. The tourists who come in thinking they have a right to treat the island any way they want for their entertainment have destroyed the way things were and should have stayed. It appears the island has become a trap, which on one hand is good for the local economy but devastating to the environment. Another great sanctuary doomed by the outsiders.

Steve Thompson
Ellsworth, Maine


Thank you, thank you, thank you. This venture has just been terrific, and it's hard to imagine how we did without you every day! I always enjoy seeing your new e-mails.
 
Even though I'm here in Louisville, I can put myself right back at the campground detour. Slide No.5 is my favorite (in the slide show). Hope to print it and put it up at school. The kids will certainly wonder what it's all about.
 
Keep up the great work and keep the postings coming. With a little more encouragement and know-how, I may even enter the podcast era just to hear the old stories.

Gloria Van Nostrand
Louisville, Ky.


Regulating ORVs on the seashore beaches

 
Let us all keep in mind that regulating ORV use on Hatteras Island should be a positive outcome for all involved, and in many instances, the saying that “less is more” rings true. I believe the Pea Island National Wildlife Refuge was established for the express reason of maintaining undisturbed habitat for coastal wildlife and flora, while national parks, such as the Cape Hatteras National Seashore, were established to allow tax-paying citizens to enjoy our natural resources with minimal constraints. I am glad Pea Island exists, and I am a big supporter of habitat conservation, but for some it is never enough, as illustrated by the recent piping plover debacle. The federal government originally established this park system with the intent of operating the beaches with minimal constraints, and this policy has allowed Hatteras Island to become the thriving, vibrant and successful community that exists today. This achievement is solely due to the ability of vacationers to enjoy these freedoms.

I would bet that the fishermen and fishermen's families made up the majority of annual visitors to the island at one time. Although over the generations, these returning families may now enjoy only driving on the beach to find the perfect spot for their beach chairs or their children to play, it has been and will always be the access to the beach that brings families and keep families coming to the Outer Banks. Everyone must continue to acknowledge this reality.

I, along with thousands of others, live close to New Jersey, Delaware, and Maryland beaches, but I have traveled to the Outer Banks for more than 20 years to enjoy the privilege to beach access my four-wheel drive. My family has literally grown up in the Buxton sand, developed life-long relationships with local families, and, hopefully, they will raise their families there long after I am gone.

Establish severe punishment for those who purposely destroy or disregard park rules. All will fully support this action, but if you take away beach access or severely constrict it, not only will the economy suffer, all families (local as well as "adopted") will suffer from the loss of what makes Hatteras Island special to begin with -- open access to its beaches.

Wayne Little
Chester Spring, Pa.




Thanks for the insight to the past and present on beach driving. The future may bring something all can live with if the parties involved meet their responsibilities to ensure what is best for Cape Hatteras National Seashore.

Dennis Pohl
Fredericksburg, Va.



Nicholas Bibbey’s Journey
 
What a wonderful story. I have a 4-year-old grandson who is autistic, and after reading Nicky's story, I am now more convinced than ever that he will have a bright and happy future. Thanks for this story of hope and inspiration.

Barbara O’Connor
Delta, Pa.



The Graveyard of the Atlantic Museum has made a successful transition into the State Division of History Museums and is on the fast track for completion. Without Nikky and his classmates and their invaluable contributions, I'm not sure that transition would have been completed. Those kids were a blessing, a gift from God.

Danny Couch
Buxton


Nicky Bibbey will always hold a special place in my heart! I had the privilege of working with Nicky when he was in the eighth grade, and I have vivid memories of when he first mastered the typing program on the computer in our classroom and when he learned to weave on the loom in the library.  I still carry a purse made from his very first piece of fabric. I am thrilled to read how well he is doing. When I have a bad day I can still hear him saying, "It will be good Miss Vicki." Way to go Nicky!

Vicki Homan
Lewes, Del.

 
 
This is a truly inspiring story. Almost everyone has some contact with autism through family or friends. This story provides another dimension to our understanding of how autism affects us all.

Mary Gray
Buxton

 
Thank you so much for sharing your story. Two of our three young boys have ASD/PDD. We have a wonderful community here in Camden. We rely so much on neighbors, school staff, public safety, and local services to keep our boys safe and on track. Congratulations to Nicky and the Bibbey family. You are an inspiration!

Jennifer Scialdone
Camden, N.C.

 
What a wonderful and well-written article about Nicky! Not only is it a testament to the Hatteras community, the schools, and all who have helped along the way, but it also gives hope to others who are traveling down similar roads with their children.

Denise B. Ziegler
Easton, Md.

 
Nicky can always make us smile. We were helping his mom move her living room around to get the Christmas tree in the house.  His Aunt Debbie picked him up from work, and when he came in the house, we all said, “Hi, Nicky.” Nicky said, “Hi, pardon me, excuse me, coming through,” as he made his way to his room. Nicky had watched the “Polar Express” the night before and that quote comes from the movie. We all got a good laugh from that. Analee and Tom, with the help of many wonderful people, have done an amazing job of tapping into what Nicky can accomplish. We are proud and grateful to them all.

Rosa-Alice Mayo
Hatteras



This is a really special article. It really touches the heart. It takes a special place to reach out in love like this. The world needs to know that there are still places where it is done. We need more reaching out and love everywhere. Keep up the good work.

Mattie O. Carpenter
McComb, Miss.



I have had the pleasure of knowing the Bibbey family for 19 years. I taught all three children. They are all special to my heart! I'm so proud of Nicky that it brings tears to my eyes. I was his music teacher for many years, and we had a lot of fun singing and looking at Disney musicals together. He never missed a beat. I still have one of his music projects that he presented in eighth grade -- a PowerPoint presentation. His smiles and happiness are genuine and contagious! Give him five minutes of your time, and you will see.

The Bibbeys are people to remember for me. Love is the key. Congratulations, Nicky.  Keep on singin’.

Ms. Joy
Joy Lawton
Portsmouth, Va.

 
 
Words can't describe the joy I have found in being Nicky's computer teacher. He never ceased to amaze me with his ability to memorize and recall information. For example, he created a database about Disney movies and was able to type the titles in alphabetical order without looking, rarely making a spelling error, keying about 40 words per minute. Also, he could tell you who produced the movie and at least two actors starring in the movie! Mrs. Georgia loves you!

Georgia Hardee
Buxton


 
The article on Nicky Bibbey is incredible! Nicholas is dear to my heart, not only because he's family, but he is an awesome, smart young man. Thank you so much for doing this piece!

Carrie Barley
Hatteras


Nicky is most definitely an amazing young man who could teach us all that there are no boundaries with limitations.  He has proven that over and over again in his 18 years.  Bravo to his family, teachers, friends, and the medical staff who all believed in his abilities to persevere.

Lorraine Burrus
Hatteras

 
This story is very heart touching, and Nicholas is truly blessed to be in a village where he is loved so much.

Judy Bragg
New Lebanon, Ohio

 
Tom (Bibbey) is a very good friend of mine. I worked with him in southwest Asia, and I am proud to know him and proud of the job they have done with Nicky. I know they are proud of him to no end.

Ron Thurman
Victoria, Va.

 
Great article on a very interesting person. It is so encouraging to other parents who may have an autistic child. Ms. Tomberlin has a great insight in what we want to know about the person. Good Job!

Nora Tomberlin
Weaverville, N.C.


I love it. Jordan did a good job.

Rachel Bibbey
Hatteras

 
Way to go, Nicky. We are so proud of you. See you at graduation!
 
Mr. Robin and Miss Jeanie Midgette
Hatteras

 
Thanks for doing the story on Nicky. Jordan did a great job. So many people don't have any ideal what autism is. I appreciate the fact that you helped bring attention to it. Like I said in the story, we have had amazing help along the way. Thanks to all of you.

Analee Bibbey
Hatteras



Temporary closing of Howard’s Pub
 
I have eaten at Howard's many times, but still wonder who Howard was. Was it Buffy all the time?

Jay Latham
Columbia, S.C.

Answer from Ann Warner, Buffy Warner’s widow and owner of Howard’s Pub:

Actually, people ask all the time who Howard is and if Howard is around at the Pub-going back from the first day we purchased the Pub in 1991.  Many people assumed Buffy was Howard and, of course, I would be Mrs. Howard.  Buffy and I bought the Pub from Ron Howard, hence the name Howard's Pub.  Ron had lived on the island for years, owning property and working.  In fact, Ron's son, Ronnie, who still lives on the island for a good part of the year, worked at the Pub for years, as did his other son, Jamie, and daughter Beth.  Buffy and I saw no reason to change the name since Howard's Pub had been around so long that it was somewhat considered an institution - or destination - with many tales to share.  I used to frequent Howard's Pub in the early ‘70s when it was across the street where Mango Loco is currently located.  It was the hot spot of the island then, as we like to think it is now.   There is a great picture of Ron Howard and Buffy hanging in the Pub. We often point to the picture when people ask and say, "That's Howard."



A photo essay on fall on the islands
 
The photos in the Nature/Enviornment section are absolutely spectacular. The color and beauty that can be found on this island are amazing. Not being on the island year round, it's nice to be able to see some of the beauty of the different seasons. Thanks for sharing.

Sharon Crislip
Fredericksburg, Va.




Podcasts of Precious Memories

Gee, Buddy, I sure hope you have LOTS more memories to share with us. I could read a book full just like this one.

Ann B. Ianuario
Jefferson, Ga.

 
Thanks, Buddy, for another great journey down memory lane.

Mary Williams
Buxton

Buddy Swain is one of the best writers I have read. I always enjoy his stories and look forward to being able to hear him read them. Presently, my computer does not allow me to do that. I like your Web site, and I am glad that it is going so well.

Betty Quinn
Atlantic Beach, N.C.


Please keep the articles coming on the Outer Banks. They bring back so many good memories. Thank you so much for all the articles. They are written so you can almost feel you are there.

Mattie O. Carpenter
McComb, Mis


These stories bring back so many memories I have of spending my summers at my grandparents’ house in Buxton during the late ‘40s and ‘50s that it actually brings tears to my eyes. I have experienced everything that these stories have brought to light. Thanks so much.


Sonny Gray
Midlothian, Va.



My husband is Jimmy Austin, and we have really enjoyed Buddy Swain’s stories.  My husband was growing up at the same time. He has pictures of Buddy’s grandfather.

Sandra Austin
Kill Devil Hills


I love these stories! Thanks for sharing and bringing back such wonderful memories of island living.

Lorraine Burrus
Hatteras

 
I'm really enjoying Buddy's stories. I'd almost forgotten Mr. Victor. He always caught me on the Slash Bridge, where I was usually fishing with Donny, Danny, and Kenny Oden. Buddy's right -- no matter how fast you moved, or how high you jumped, he always hit his target. I loved that man but sure hated that tobacco juice!

Mary B. Williams
Buxton

 
If only we could go back in time, back to the good ol' days -- if only for a day.

Joanie Canipe
Kill Devil Hills

 
 
I feel as if I am with you all in your stories -- what precious memories and humor. Thank you for sharing with all of us. Waiting for the next chapter.

Rosa-Alice Mayo
Hatteras



Your podcast series by Buddy Swain is indeed fun, descriptive, and educational about Hatteras long ago. If I close my eyes while listening, I can envision myself with him and his family doing all kinds of fun, kid stuff. Thanks Buddy and Cliff!
 
Tom Adams
Columbus, Ohio


I loved Buddy's story, though I couldn't get the audio going. The Hadeco figures in my parent's stories of visits to the island during the time frame of Buddy's adventure. Here is what my father told me about it:

"The first car drove onto the deck over a barn door-looking ramp. They bounced it until it was right up against the wheelhouse. The bumpers were out over the sides of the boat with the axles tied to the rail. The second car was driven on board and bounced right up next to the first one, with its right side wheels on the deck and driver's side wheels on the rails. And the third car, its forward wheels were completely outside the rails."

One of their crossings was stormy, too. The water was so rough that the back end of the family Chevrolet came untied. The boat rode up the steep front sides of the waves, and as it came down hard on the back sides the loose end of the car hung momentarily in the air. Then blam, blam. From the wheelhouse, the passengers could see a crew member hanging onto the rope trying to re-tie it. He disappeared in each wave but finally got the car secured. Then my mother got sick. She was on the deck with the waves breaking over her while Dad held onto her from just inside the wheelhouse. She was throwing up constantly, begging him to turn her loose and just let her go.

All of Buddy's stories that I have read are wonderful, even when they make me cry.

Ann Ianuario
Jefferson, Ga.


I finally got to listen. Thank you, Buddy!


Ann Ianuario
Jefferson, Ga
 
I am so glad to see another of Buddy Swain's stories. They make you feel like you are there. Please keep them coming!

Analee Bibbey
Hatteras

 
Not only am I enjoying reading “Going to Grandmom's,” but I also enjoying listening to it on my mp3 player. Although I knew what RSS feed was, I was not familiar with just how it worked. As I struggle to learn all about RSS feeds, my reward is listening to a great story. I guess you can teach an old dog new tricks.  I gotta tell you that this is a lot of fun. Life is good!

Dennis Pohl
Fredericksburg, Va.

 
Thank you so much for Buddy Swain's “Precious Memories” podcast. I wanted to hear it so much that you convinced me to learn how to download a podcast and get an mp3 player. I can't wait to hear the next one.

Liz Browning Fox
Chapel Hill, N.C.

 
I'm already in love with Buddy Swain’s stories and the wonderful way he tells them. I felt like I was on the boat with him going to Grandmom's house. I'm looking forward to more wonderful stories. Thank you for sharing.

Joanie Canipe
Kill Devil Hills

I dearly love Buddy Swain’s stories of his early childhood memories in Hatteras village with his grandparents. He really takes us with him on his adventures. Thanks for sharing with us, Buddy.

Lorraine Burrus
Hatteras


 
WOW! WOW! WOW!  I adore Buddy's stories and no one can tell them better than he.  Thank you for this wonderful new addition to the already amazing Island Free Press. I anxiously await the others in the series. The islands are so beautifully reflected in all you do.

Lynne Foster
Hatteras


 
I think the podcast with Buddy Swain is the best idea yet. Of course, I am one of Buddy’s biggest fans.  He is a very talented man. I am glad he lives in my neighborhood. Hearing the stories makes it so much better. The podcast just makes The Island Free Press that much more entertaining.

Beth Bailey
Hatteras
 
 

Buddy Swain carries you right to the action with his brilliant descriptions and entertaining way of telling of his experiences. We can't wait for the next installment.

John Morgan
Washington, N.C.




Thankful for American heroes

I am thankful that there have been people that were willing to sacrifice for the greater good. I’ve encountered many people since moving here to Hatteras village, all of whom I have come to know and to respect, but there is a unique trio of men who were born a little more than 80 years ago that have caught my imagination and more importantly captured my heartfelt appreciation.

Lester Ballance, Damon Gray Jr., and Daniel Willis embody my definition of an American hero. These Hatterasmen have given their community and their country a reason to be proud. I am eternally grateful for men such as these and their band of brothers. Their selfless acts of sacrifice gave rise to what is referred to today as “The Greatest Generation.”

Imagine, three young men in a war-torn world fighting an enemy that most of us would never have to know because of their self-sacrificing nature. It is profound that these men were ready to die for a generation not yet born. They left behind their moms and dads, sisters and brothers, sweethearts and friends, never knowing if they would ever return, but yet the call of duty, their love of country, and the desire to preserve a way of life was far more important to them than their own lives.

The sacrifice they were willing to give is bewildering, especially at a time in our history when the current generation knows nothing of sacrifice. God forbid the iPod loses its charge or the Internet is down.
 
Let us give thanks to our Heavenly Father who has blessed us with the lives of these great patriots, whom I revere as true American heroes.

Kevin Conner
Hatteras




A life with no left turns

My parents passed away some time ago, and I think of them often. This story reminds me of the many great times we had as a family and all the great times we're having with our kids and grandmonsters. Thanks for reprinting this great story.

Mike Denniston
Wilmington, N.C.




What a great article -- so full of life, love, and simple happiness. Michael Gartner’s writing is as wonderful as his parents were precious. Thank you for this personal glimpse in your family's life.

Clifford Swain
Hatteras




Surfing 2007

Awesome surf photos.

Misty Gillikin
Buxton
 

Thank you! Those are absolutely wonderful surfing pictures. You brightened my cold, dreary morning here in West Virginia.

Darren Mayfield
Weirton, W.Va.

 
Thank you for the excellent surfing articles and photos by Daniel Pullen. I never knew the easy going guy working at Natural Art was so talented. Turns out he's also an artist and also does artwork on In the Eye Surfboards. His excellent writing in The Island Free Press is a breath of fresh air to all who truly love surfing Hatteras. By the way, 2007 was a year of waiting for good surf here in New Jersey, too. Hope our patience pays off in 2008!

Michael Letso
Chadwick Beach, N.J.


 
Thank you so much for publishing such a great newspaper. I look forward to stopping and reading it. The slide show of the surfing pictures was awesome.

Michelle Reitz
Virginia Beach

 
Great story and even better pictures.

Allen Burrus
Hatteras





A thank you to the island from Nikki and Richie


Many thanks for the outpouring of charity and care that we have received from the people of Hatteras Island. We hope that through The Island Free Press we can get our message of thanks to all of those businesses, teachers, school kids, and individuals whom we have missed with our mailings. Your generosity and kindness are so very appreciated. We are blessed.

Nikki and Richie Spears
Hatteras




Women Kiteboarders
 
I loved Pam Bailey's article on women kiteboarders over 40. I am new to the sport at 43, on a slow, but fun and challenging learning curve. Thank you, Pam, for proving that women are more than willing and able to kick it out there with the youngsters. I look forward to meeting some of the cool women in your article when we start trekking out to the Outer Banks this spring and summer.

Stacey Anderegg
Chapel Hill



Waterfront access funds

This is in response to the articles concerning waterfront access funding in Dare County. Anybody who has been involved in this process from the start knows that the original name for this was “working waterfront initiative.” The intent was to help the fishing industry survive the onslaught of regulations and development and to help keep the access and the financial support that the industry provides to coastal communities. Taking notice of some of the projects that have moved to the top of the list makes me wonder if this isn't just an "old pal" bailout.

First, Avon harbor has a working fish house, boat ramp, parking, so why would the government want to spend money here to impose on private enterprise? In Buxton, there is Scott’s Boatyard with slips, and Dare County owns property at the same location in Buxton Harbor. In Frisco, Frisco Cove Marina has slips, a ramp, and parking.  And on down in Hatteras village are Oden’s Dock, Hatteras Harbor Marina, Teach's Lair, and Hatteras Landing.  All are struggling for business and struggling with payments, and all are supporting their communities.  Yet the government wants to come in and kick the legs out from under them by putting up competing, state-funded ramps, dockage, and so forth.

If the recreational sector is so lucrative, why doesn't one of the many tackle shops borrow the money like the rest of us have had to do and make a fortune? Why? Because it just isn't there. This is just a "buddy, ol’ pal" bailout of interest-only loans gone bad at the expense of all the people who have taken a chance at business. It’s one thing to fail at business, but entirely another when the government bails you out in the name of conservation.  

Tilman Gray
Avon
Member of Waterfront Access Advisory Committee


 
We need public access to the sound from Buxton. The plan outlined in this article will give needed expansion and convenience to Buxton boat owners who wish to fish and explore the Pamlico Sound.
 
John Rice
Aids to Navigation Officer
Coast Guard Auxiliary 1604
Buxton




Gamefish status for striped bass and red drum

Thanks to Ernie Foster for a reasoned view of gamefish status for striped bass and channel bass (red drum).
 
I am a recreational angler, but I have never understood the desire to eliminate one user group or the other from a fishery. If the point of gamefish status is to preserve fish, shouldn't gamefish status also come with a no-harvest provision for recreational anglers? And even if every striper or channel bass is released, there will still be some mortality associated with the fishery, as numerous scientific studies have shown.
 
While many recreational anglers practice catch and release for both striped bass and channel bass, it's obvious from the most recent harvest of 2.1 million pounds of ocean striped bass that many anglers are keeping some of their catch. And that's fine -- a striped bass is one of the tastiest fish in the sea. It does, however, seem illogical to say, "I can kill fish with a rod and reel, but you can't with a net."
 
A dead fish is a dead fish, no matter how it reached its end.

Jim Wilson
Chapel Hill, N.C.



Getting to and from Ocracoke this winter
 
November and December have been the quietest in our recollection. It's as if people think the road is already closed!

DOT termed this project one of "no significant impact" on humans or the environment. Ms. Nolan has described very well the extensive, quite significant efforts made by many agencies to try to offset this disruption.

We look forward to spring!

Fred Westervelt
Ocracoke




Problems with overwash on Highway 12
 
It is a shame that North Carolina doesn't charge a small access fee to out-of-state vehicles. The non-resident fee could be collected at the Hatteras ferry dock and Whalebone with proceeds earmarked for NCDOT maintenance of Highway 12.

Charles Peele


   


 Comments are always welcomed!


     Subject :

     Name :  (required)

     Email :  (required, will not be published)

     City :   (required)    State :   (required)

     Your Comments:

May be posted on the Letters to the Editor page at the discretion of the editor.